Battery vs hardwired motorized screen: which should you get?
Get a hardwired motor unless you have no practical way to bring power to the head box. Then a solar battery motor is fine, as long as the screen is small enough, gets direct sun and has a free-hanging bottom bar. The limit is torque. The solar screen motors in the maker documents we read stop at 10 Nm (Somfy Sunea 40 Solar io, Simu AutoSun), while Elero's hardwired zip-screen motors run up to 30 Nm. By the sizing method in our motorized patio screens guide, 10 Nm runs out at about a 12 ft wide, 8 ft drop solar zip screen, with nothing left over for margin. Somfy also restricts its solar screen motor to screens "without locks" whose bottom bar falls by gravity and weighs under 15 kg.
Key takeaways
- Solar battery screen motors: 6 or 10 Nm (Somfy Sunea 40 Solar io), 3, 6 or 10 Nm (Simu AutoSun). Hardwired zip motors: 4 to 30 Nm (Elero SunTop/Z).
- By our calculation, a 10 Nm battery motor covers a zip screen of about 10 x 8 ft with margin. A 12 x 8 ft solar zip screen needs the full 10 Nm.
- The Somfy and Simu batteries are 12 V, 2.2 Ah: about 26 Wh. That works out to roughly 25 full cycles of an 8 ft screen with no sun, close to Simu's "15 days without sun, 2 cycles per day."
- Somfy's solar screen motor charges only between 0°C and 40°C (32-104°F). In a freezing spell the screen runs on stored charge.
- Battery life is about 8 years by Somfy's estimate (at a 20°C average). A hardwired motor has no battery to replace.
Battery vs hardwired at a glance
| Question | Solar battery motor | Hardwired motor |
|---|---|---|
| Torque range read | 3-10 Nm (Simu AutoSun, Somfy Sunea 40 Solar io); 12 Nm on Elero's 12 V VariEco M DC | 4-30 Nm (Elero SunTop/Z, made for zip screens) |
| Speed at the top torque | 12 rpm at 10 Nm | 14 rpm at 10, 20 and 30 Nm; 23 rpm at 12 Nm |
| Bottom bar | Sunea 40 Solar io: falls by gravity, under 15 kg, no locks | No bar rule on Elero's zip motor page |
| Power store | 12 V, 2.2 Ah battery (about 26 Wh) plus a 3.2 W panel | House circuit |
| Use per day | "10 cycles per day," thermal limit 4 minutes (Sunea 40 listing) | No daily cap stated on Elero's page |
| Charging temperature | 0°C to 40°C (32-104°F) | Not applicable |
| Parts that wear out | Battery, about 8 years | Motor only |
| Maker warranty | Sunea 40 Solar io 7 years; AutoSun 5 years | Varies by maker |
| Installation | No circuit; panel needs direct sun | Circuit to the head box |
Is a battery motor as strong as a plug-in one?
Two answers circulate: that a battery motor now does the same job, and that battery is only for small shades. The second is closer. The first comes from treating every battery motor as one product, when indoor battery shade motors, exterior solar screen motors and hardwired screen motors are three different things.
Exterior solar screen motors are their own group: Somfy sells its Sunea 40 WireFree io as 6 Nm at 18 rpm or 10 Nm at 12 rpm, and the Simu AutoSun 2 data sheet lists 3 Nm at 23 rpm, 6 Nm at 18 rpm and 10 Nm at 12 rpm, all at 12 V DC. The strongest 12 V motor we found was Elero's VariEco M DC, 10 or 12 Nm at 16 rpm, sold as a "tubular motor for solar drive systems."
Hardwired motors start where those stop. Elero's SunTop/Z M RH, a hardwired motor for zip screens, comes as 4 Nm at 60 rpm, 7/23, 10/14, 12/23, 20/14 and 30 Nm at 14 rpm. So a battery motor is as strong as a hardwired one only up to 10-12 Nm. Above that there is no battery option in the documents we read. How the motor, brake and limit unit fit inside the tube is in tubular motor internals.
The screen size where 10 Nm runs out
Torque needed is the hanging weight times gravity times the radius of the fully rolled screen. Our motorized patio screen guide doubles the result for a zip track, because the zip strip drags in its channel. Apply the same method to screens of the sizes a battery motor gets asked to lift.
| Screen (width x drop) | Mesh | Hanging weight | Torque needed | 10 Nm battery motor? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 10 x 8 ft (3.05 x 2.44 m) | Insect mesh, 0.1 lb/sq ft | 8.2 kg | 7.7 Nm | Yes, with margin |
| 10 x 8 ft | SunTex 90, 17.2 oz/yd² | 8.9 kg | 8.4 Nm | Yes, little margin |
| 12 x 8 ft (3.66 x 2.44 m) | Insect mesh | 9.8 kg | 9.3 Nm | Only just |
| 12 x 8 ft | SunTex 90 | 10.6 kg | 10.0 Nm | No margin; go hardwired |
The SunTex weight is Phifer's figure from our SunTex 80 vs 90 vs 95 comparison.
Two things move the line. A cable-guided or free-hanging screen does not pay the zip doubling, so the same 10 Nm lifts about twice the weight; the trade-offs of losing the zip are in zip screen vs cable-guided screen. A thicker roller or a longer drop raises the radius and the torque with it. Motorized screen housing sizes shows which housing each width needs.
Bottom bar rules: no locks, under 15 kg
Somfy's Sunea 40 Solar io instructions (2022) say the motor is designed "to drive all types of external vertical screens (without locks)," and only an "external vertical screen which front rail moves solely by gravity with a mass less than 15 kg." Any other use is "prohibited" and voids the warranty.
That rules the solar motor out of two kinds of screen. Zip screens with a locking bottom bar, which latch into the side channels to hold down in wind, are not "without locks." Screens with a spring-tensioned bottom bar do not fall "solely by gravity." The 15 kg limit rarely bites: a 1 lb per ft bar on a 14 ft screen is about 6.4 kg.
How many cycles a battery holds
Both Somfy systems use a 12 V, 2.2 Ah battery. Somfy's Oximo WireFree Battery Stick, one of the three batteries the Sunea 40 Solar io may be paired with, lists 2.2 Ah; the AutoSun battery is Ni-MH, 12 V, 2.2 Ah. That stores about 26 Wh. Somfy UK gives the Sunea 40 Solar io's consumption during operation as 26 W, so a full battery is at most about an hour of motor running.
An hour is more than it sounds. On a 40 mm tube, an 8 ft (2.44 m) drop of 1 mm fabric takes about 14 turns, or 71 seconds each way at 12 rpm. A full cycle, down and up, is about 2.4 minutes and 1.0 Wh, so a full battery holds roughly 25 cycles with no sun at all. Simu claims "15 days without sun, 2 cycles per day" for AutoSun, 30 cycles. The two figures agree closely. Our estimate is a ceiling: Somfy's battery manual says the motor will not draw it below 10 V.
The panel puts it back. AutoSun's panel is rated 3.2 W, the same rating Somfy requires for the Sunea 40 Solar io. At full rating it replaces one 1.0 Wh cycle in about 20 minutes of sun. Real output in partial sun is lower, which is why panel placement decides whether a solar screen works.
Cold, shade and the twice-a-year rule
The Sunea 40 Solar io operates from -20°C to 70°C but charges only from 0°C to 40°C (32-104°F). A week below freezing means a week of stored charge only. The window closes again above 40°C (104°F).
Somfy's battery manual gives a clear test for a badly placed panel. The battery should need charging from the external charger at most twice a year ("2 par an maxi"). If it needs it several times a year, Somfy names three causes: the panel is badly placed, the panel is faulty, or the battery is at the end of its life. Somfy estimates that life at about 8 years at a 20°C average. The manual also describes how the system warns of a low battery, on Somfy's shutter motor: above 11.5 V it runs normally. Between 10 and 11.5 V it pauses on the way up, or jogs twice instead of going down. Below 10 V it will not move.
So a north-facing porch, a deep lanai or a screen under a roof overhang is a hardwired job. The panel can be moved away from the screen (AutoSun sells a 5 m extension cable), but Somfy limits the motor-to-battery cable to 2.5 m at 0.75 mm².
Daily use and sensors
The Dutch dealer listing for the Sunea 40 WireFree io gives a maximum of "10 cycles per day," a 4-minute thermal limit and "not suitable for continuous use." AutoSun's end-limit system limits operation to 3 minutes per run. That covers a screen lowered in the afternoon and raised at night. It does not cover a screen driven by a sun sensor on a day of passing clouds, or one that a household runs up and down all day.
The Sunea 40 Solar io works with Somfy's Sunis WF io wireless sun sensor, and AutoSun with Simu Hz transmitters and its Hz sun sensor. Which smart home hub can reach the motor depends on its radio, not its power source; see Bond Bridge Pro vs Somfy TaHoma. Before relying on any automation, confirm the wind sensor you want pairs with the battery motor; how sensors protect a screen is covered in sun and wind sensors. Both solar motors stop on an obstacle, as do Elero's hardwired zip motors, which add "blockage detection up."
What installing each one takes
A hardwired screen needs a circuit at the head box. That is easy in new construction and costly in a finished soffit; the patio screen guide puts electrical work at about $150-500 per circuit run, and the wiring step itself is in installing motorized patio screens.
A solar screen needs no circuit, but it is not a do-it-yourself shortcut. Somfy requires the Sunea 40 Solar io to be "installed by a home motorisation and automation professional," with the battery fully charged before installation. Its antenna has to extend at least 10 cm outside the housing, and two motors have to be at least 20 cm apart. Setting the limits is the same job on either power source; the button sequences are in how to reset the limits on a motorized screen.
For price, the Dutch dealer lists the Sunea 40 WireFree io motor alone at €219.95 (6 Nm) and €244.95 (10 Nm) including tax; the battery and panel are sold separately. Installed screen prices are in retractable screen cost.
Which to choose
- Hardwired: any zip screen wider than about 10 ft at an 8 ft drop, any locking or tensioned bottom bar, shaded or north-facing openings, frequent or sensor-driven use, and new builds where a circuit costs little to run now.
- Solar battery: a retrofit with no power near the head box, a screen within the torque table above, a gravity bottom bar, a panel position in direct sun, and a few cycles a day.
When this comparison stops applying
- Other makers. The torque ceilings come from the Somfy, Simu and Elero documents linked here. A maker with a stronger battery motor moves the size line; ask for its torque in Nm and its bottom bar rules.
- Low-voltage wired systems. 12-24 V DC motors fed from a central power supply are hardwired with no battery. The battery limits above do not apply to them.
- The torque table is an estimate. It assumes a 78 mm roller, 1 mm fabric and a 1 lb per ft bar. The screen maker's motor chart for the exact model overrides it.
Bottom line
Hardwire wherever you can reach power: it has the full torque range to 30 Nm, no battery to replace and no limit on use. Choose solar battery only for a retrofit screen of about 10 x 8 ft or less with a gravity bottom bar and a panel in direct sun. That is where a 10 Nm motor and a 26 Wh battery have room to spare. On a 12 ft solar zip screen the best battery motor we read is already at its limit.
Frequently asked questions
Does a solar screen still work in a power cut?
Yes. It runs from its own battery and has no connection to the house supply. A hardwired screen stops unless it has a manual override; see how to raise a motorized screen when the power is out.
Can I convert a hardwired screen to solar later?
Only by changing the motor, and only if the screen fits the solar motor's limits: torque of 10 Nm or less, a tube of 37 mm inside diameter or more for the Sunea 40 Solar io, and a gravity bottom bar with no locks.
Sources and standards consulted
- Energy Efficient Window Attachments (U.S. Department of Energy, Energy Saver)
- EN 13561:2015, External blinds and awnings (CEN)
- ASCE 7, Minimum Design Loads for Buildings (wind and snow loads) (American Society of Civil Engineers)
See how we research for our sourcing and verification process.