SheerWeave vs SunTex for exterior solar screens

For an exterior solar screen, SunTex is the fabric made for the job, and SheerWeave is a shade fabric that is allowed outside. Both come from the same mill, Phifer. SunTex is a vinyl-coated polyester mesh that Phifer calls "ideal" for shading "windows, doors and porches," with a 10-year exterior warranty. SheerWeave 2500, 2410, 2390 and 2360 are vinyl-coated fiberglass fabrics for roller shades and panel tracks. Phifer says they "can also be used in exterior shading systems," on a 5-year exterior warranty. Pick SheerWeave outside only when you need 1-5% openness in a thin fabric on a roller. A 3% SheerWeave is not "a stronger SunTex." It is a thinner fabric made of a different yarn, rated for indoor use first.

Key takeaways

  • SunTex is Phifer's exterior screen fabric (polyester yarn). SheerWeave is Phifer's shade fabric line (fiberglass yarn), and some styles are also approved outside.
  • Openness: SheerWeave 2500/2410/2390/2360 are about 1/3/5/10% open. SunTex 80 and 90 are about 25% and 10% open.
  • SheerWeave is about half as thick: 0.017-0.024 in against 0.039-0.040 in for SunTex. On a roller, that means a smaller roll.
  • Warranty outside: SheerWeave 5 years, SunTex 10 years. Both pay in fabric only, not labor.
  • The SheerWeave heat (SHGC) table is for fabric mounted inside the glass. It cannot be compared with SunTex's exterior figures.

What SheerWeave and SunTex are

Both names are Phifer trademarks, and both fabrics are a woven mesh of coated yarn. The difference is the yarn and the job each line was built for.

SunTex is a solar screen fabric: a mesh that hangs outside the glass and stops the sun before it reaches the window. Phifer's SunTex 80/90 card (version V18B) calls it an "exterior shading fabric" of "strong vinyl-coated polyester." It was "Developed originally for use in outdoor furniture." The card adds that SunTex "is also pet resistant."

SheerWeave is a family of shade fabrics, sold mostly for roller shades. Each style has a number. Phifer's card for styles 2500, 2400 (2410), 2900 (2390) and 2600 (2360) is hosted by the shade maker Draper. It calls them "lightweight, vinyl-coated fiberglass fabrics, with full basketweave." Its "Standard uses" line reads "Roller shades and panel tracks." Then it adds one sentence: "These styles can also be used in exterior shading systems."

The numbers in brackets matter. The card lists 2410 beside 2400, 2390 beside 2900 and 2360 beside 2600. Distributors and Phifer's exterior warranty use the bracketed numbers, so a quote for an outdoor screen will usually say 2410 or 2390.

Openness factor: the share of the fabric that is open holes. A 3% fabric is 97% yarn. Lower openness blocks more sun and more view. Glossary: openness factor.

SheerWeave and SunTex side by side

Phifer SheerWeave 2500/2410/2390/2360 vs SunTex 80 and 90 (figures from the two Phifer cards linked above)
PropertySheerWeave 2500SheerWeave 2410SheerWeave 2390SheerWeave 2360SunTex 90SunTex 80
Openness factorAbout 1%About 3%About 5%About 10%About 10%About 25%
UV blockedAbout 99%About 97%About 95%About 90%About 90%About 75%
Visible light through (TV)2-15%3-17%6-22%11-27%18-20%36-39%
YarnFiberglassFiberglassFiberglassFiberglassPolyesterPolyester
Weight, oz/yd²16.214.111.810.417.213.5
Thickness0.024 in0.020 in0.017 in0.019 in0.039 in0.040 in
Widths63, 98 and 126 in36-96 in; 120 in except Grey36-96 in
Standard uses on the cardRoller shades and panel tracks; "can also be used in exterior shading systems"Shading fabric on windows, doors and porches
NFPA 701 on the cardTM#1 and TM#2Not named
Warranty10-year interior, 5-year exterior10-year exterior

The TV ranges cover every color on each card. SheerWeave TV is at a 0° profile angle (sun straight on). SunTex TV is the same at 30° and 75° on its card. Dark colors sit at the low end of each range.

Is a 3% SheerWeave a stronger SunTex?

No. Lower openness makes it darker, not stronger, and almost nothing else on the two cards lines up.

The idea comes from reading every solar fabric on one scale of openness. SunTex 80 is about 25% open and SunTex 90 about 10%, so a 3% SheerWeave 2410 looks like the next step up. Dealer pages feed that view. The Phantom Screens dealer blog "All You Need to Know About Solar Mesh" lists SunTex 80 colors and SheerWeave 1000 colors side by side, and says nothing else about SheerWeave. A reader comes away thinking they are two grades of one product.

Read the cards and three things differ besides openness:

  • The yarn. SheerWeave 2410 is 36% fiberglass and 64% vinyl. SunTex is 31% polyester and 69% vinyl.
  • The build. SheerWeave 2410 is 0.020 in thick. SunTex 90 is 0.039 in, almost twice as thick.
  • The rating outside. SheerWeave carries 5 years in exterior systems. SunTex carries 10.

Strength cannot settle it either way. The SunTex card gives breaking strength of 400 lb (SunTex 80) and 480 lb (SunTex 90) along the length. The SheerWeave card gives no strength figure at all.

If what you want is SunTex at 3% open, Phifer makes it. A SunTex 95/97/99 dealer listing describes them as "full basketweave vinyl-coated polyester fabric for exterior roller shade applications," about 5/3/1% open. They come only in 126 in rolls. How those compare with SunTex 80 and 90 is in SunTex 80 vs 90 vs 95.

Worked example: a west porch screen, 10 ft wide

Walkthrough: Take a motorized screen on a west porch opening 10 ft wide with an 8 ft (96 in) drop, wound on a 70 mm (2.76 in) tube. Suppose low sun and glare are the problem, so the choice is between SunTex 90 (about 10% open) and SheerWeave 2410 (about 3% open).
Width. 10 ft is 120 in. SheerWeave 2410 comes 126 in wide, so one piece covers it. SunTex 90 comes 120 in wide in every color except Grey, so it just fits, with nothing left for hems.
Roll size. Roll diameter = square root of (tube diameter² + 4 x thickness x length / π), fabric only. SheerWeave 2410 at 0.020 in gives about 3.17 in (80 mm). SunTex 90 at 0.039 in gives about 3.52 in (89 mm).
Weight. The panel is 80 sq ft, about 8.9 yd². SheerWeave 2410 at 14.1 oz/yd² weighs about 7.8 lb. SunTex 90 at 17.2 oz/yd² weighs about 9.6 lb.
Daylight. In Charcoal, SheerWeave 2410 passes 3% of visible light. Black SunTex 90 passes 19%. The 2410 room is far darker and the view out far dimmer.
Warranty. 5 years for the 2410 outside, 10 for SunTex 90.

So the SheerWeave screen is lighter and rolls about 1/3 in smaller, which helps in a tight housing. It gives up most of the daylight and half the warranty. If the porch is a place you sit and look out from, SunTex 90 fits the job. If the screen is mostly down to kill glare on a TV wall or to give daytime privacy, the 3% fabric earns its place. How the roll decides the housing is shown in motorized screen housing sizes.

Heat: why the two SHGC tables cannot be compared

Both cards print a table of SHGC, the share of the sun's heat that gets through glass and fabric together (lower is cooler; see SHGC). The tables do not measure the same setup.

The SunTex rows are headed "Fabrics Installed Externally," at 30° and 75° profile angles. The SheerWeave footnote reads "Fabrics Installed Internally, Zero-Degree Profile Angle." So the SheerWeave figures, 0.25-0.62 on 1/4 in clear glass, are for a shade hanging inside the window. A fabric outside the glass stops the sun before it heats the glass. Inside, the heat is already in the room. Set side by side, the two tables would make SheerWeave look far worse outside than it may be. No Phifer document we read gives an exterior SHGC for SheerWeave.

What the cards do allow is a look at the fabric itself. At 0°, Charcoal SheerWeave 2410 passes 3% of solar energy (TS). Black SunTex 90 passes 12% at 30°. The angles differ, so take that only as a sign that the 3% fabric lets less sun through. It is not a heat figure for your room.

Color moves heat inside each family as well. On the SheerWeave card, solar reflectance runs from 4% (Charcoal) to 72% (Brite White). On SunTex 80 at 30° it runs from 4% (Black) to 38% (Stucco). The same Textilene comparison, with SunTex's SHGC figures in full, is in Textilene vs SunTex.

UV and view

On UV, lower openness wins. SheerWeave 2500, 2410 and 2390 block about 99%, 97% and 95% of UV. SunTex 90 blocks about 90% and SunTex 80 about 75%. SheerWeave 2360 and SunTex 90 match on paper: both about 10% open and about 90% UV blocked.

The cost is light and view. Every SheerWeave style in this group passes less visible light than SunTex 80 in any color. Only the light colors of 2360 and 2390 reach the 18-20% of SunTex 90. If keeping the view from a porch matters more than fading, SunTex keeps more of it.

One more source of mix-ups: retail "SheerWeave solar screen." Metro Screenworks sells a SheerWeave roll in white "vinyl-coated fiberglass" that "Blocks up to 75% of UV rays," in 48 and 72 in widths. That is a different style from the four on the Draper card. When a page says SheerWeave blocks 75%, it is describing that style, not 2410.

Fire ratings, warranty and care

Fire. The SheerWeave card names NFPA 701 TM#1 (small scale) and TM#2 (large scale), plus NFPA 101 Class A and California Title 19. Trivantage's SheerWeave 2410 listing gives the edition as "NFPA 701-2004 TM#1." The SunTex card names California TB 117-2013, CAN/ULC-S 109-03, and Class A under NFPA 101 and IBC 803.1.1, but not NFPA 701. So on a commercial job where the fire marshal asks for NFPA 701, the SheerWeave card answers it and the SunTex card does not. Each fabric's listing, with edition and test method, is in which solar screen fabrics are NFPA 701 rated.

Warranty. Phifer's SheerWeave Exterior warranty (V09, 2009) names styles 2360, 2390, 2410 and 2500 "for normal use in exterior systems." It runs five years against the fabric becoming "nonfunctional." It does not cover damage or "gradual fading," and it replaces fabric, not labor. Phifer's Exterior Sun Control warranty gives SunTex the same terms for 10 years, and names it "for use in retractable roller systems." What those terms mean for a screen's real life is in how long do solar screens last.

Care. Phifer's SheerWeave cleaning sheet allows mild soap and water on 2360, 2390, 2410 and 2500, or bleach diluted to 10% or less. The metallized Performance+ versions of 2390, 2410 and 2500 are different: "Do not scrub." The SunTex card asks only for "occasional cleaning with mild soap and water." The rules for each fabric are in how to clean retractable and solar screens.

Which one to choose

  • Fixed screens on windows and doors: SunTex 80 or 90. It is the fabric Phifer names for windows, doors and porches, it comes in narrow widths from 36 in, and it carries 10 years outside.
  • Porch or patio roll-down where you want the view: SunTex 90, or SunTex 95 if the screen maker lists it for the housing.
  • Roll-down for glare or daytime privacy, small housing: SheerWeave 2410 or 2500 if the screen maker approves it. Expect a dark room and a 5-year fabric warranty.
  • Commercial job that needs NFPA 701 on paper: SheerWeave, which names it on its card. Ask Phifer for an NFPA 701 report before you specify SunTex.
  • Matching an existing outdoor shade: the style already in it. Read the style number off the old quote or label, not the brand name.

What this comparison does not cover

This page sets four SheerWeave styles against SunTex 80 and 90, on Phifer's own cards. It says nothing about the other SheerWeave lines (the 4000, 7000 and Infinity series, and the retail style 1000 beyond its UV claim), which have their own sheets. It does not give a heat figure for SheerWeave outside the glass, because no document we read has one. Pet resistance is claimed on the SunTex card only, and neither card gives an insect or wind rating. The fabric is also only half the decision on a roll-down screen. Whether a housing, motor and zip edge are rated for a given fabric is the screen maker's call. Get its approval in writing before you swap one fabric for another.

Bottom line

SunTex is Phifer's exterior screen fabric: polyester, about 25% or 10% open, about 75% or 90% UV blocked, 10 years outside. SheerWeave 2500, 2410, 2390 and 2360 are fiberglass shade fabrics, about 1-10% open and 90-99% UV blocked. They are half as thick and allowed outside on a 5-year warranty. Use SunTex where you want light and a view, and SheerWeave where you want a dark, thin roll-down that the screen maker approves. Do not compare the SheerWeave SHGC table with SunTex: it is for a shade inside the glass.

Sources

Frequently asked questions

Is SheerWeave made by Phifer?

Yes. SheerWeave and SunTex are both registered trademarks of Phifer Incorporated. SheerWeave is its shade fabric line and SunTex its exterior solar screen fabric.

Can SheerWeave be used outside?

Some styles can. Phifer's card says 2500, 2410, 2390 and 2360 "can also be used in exterior shading systems," and its exterior warranty covers them for 5 years. Not every SheerWeave style is on that list.

Is SheerWeave 2360 the same as SunTex 90?

On openness and UV, yes: both are about 10% open and about 90% UV blocked. SheerWeave 2360 is fiberglass, 0.019 in thick and 10.4 oz/yd². SunTex 90 is polyester, 0.039 in and 17.2 oz/yd², with twice the exterior warranty.

Which is darker, SheerWeave 2410 or SunTex 90?

SheerWeave 2410. It passes 3-17% of visible light by color, against 18-20% for SunTex 90.

Can I use the SheerWeave SHGC numbers for an outdoor screen?

No. The card states they are for fabrics installed internally, at a 0° sun angle. They describe a shade inside the window, not a screen outside it.

Sources and standards consulted

  • Energy Efficient Window Attachments (U.S. Department of Energy, Energy Saver)
  • EN 13561:2015, External blinds and awnings (CEN)
  • ASCE 7, Minimum Design Loads for Buildings (wind and snow loads) (American Society of Civil Engineers)

See how we research for our sourcing and verification process.