Textilene vs SunTex: which solar screen fabric is better?

Neither is better across the board. Tier for tier they cut the same heat: Twitchell's sheet gives Textilene 80 a shading coefficient of 0.33 on single clear glass (SHGC about 0.29), and Phifer's card gives SunTex 80 an SHGC of 0.29-0.32. The rest of the sheet separates them. SunTex blocks more UV at the same number (about 75% for SunTex 80 against 67-71% for Textilene 80). Textilene is thinner and lighter, and Textilene 80 and 90 come 126 in wide, which SunTex 80 and 90 do not. Pick SunTex where fading is the problem, Textilene where you need a wide seamless panel or a smaller roll.

Key takeaways

  • Heat is a tie within each tier. 80 grades: SHGC about 0.29 (Textilene, 0°) and 0.29-0.32 (SunTex, 30°). 90 grades: about 0.20 and 0.17-0.19.
  • Openness is close: Textilene 80 is 23% open and SunTex 80 approximately 25%. Textilene 90 is 13% and SunTex 90 approximately 10%. Neither "80" is 20% open.
  • UV goes to SunTex: approximately 75% and 90% blocked, against 67-71% for Textilene 80 and 85% for Textilene 90 on Twitchell's own sheet.
  • Textilene 80 and 90 are 0.033-0.035 in thick, SunTex 80 and 90 0.039-0.040 in.
  • Two different fabrics are sold as "Textilene 95": Nano 95 (0.026 in, 14.7 oz/yd²) and a heavier Textilene 95 (0.0409 in, 17.3 oz/yd²). Ask which one a quote means.

Textilene and SunTex side by side

Twitchell Textilene vs Phifer SunTex, 80 and 90 grades (figures from the makers' sheets linked below)
PropertyTextilene 80SunTex 80Textilene 90SunTex 90
Openness factor23%Approximately 25%13%Approximately 10%
UV blocked67% (0°), 71% (45°)Approximately 75%85% (0°)Approximately 90%
Solar transmittance24% (0°), 20% (45°)26-31% (30°)13% (0°), 9% (45°)12-17% (30°)
Visible transmittance21% (0°)36-39%14% (0°)18-20%
SHGC on 1/8 in clear glassAbout 0.29 (SC 0.33, 0°)0.29-0.32 (30°)About 0.20 (SC 0.23, 0°)0.17-0.19 (30°)
Weight13.0 oz/yd²13.5 oz/yd²15.8 oz/yd²17.2 oz/yd²
Thickness0.0328 in (0.83 mm)0.040 in (1.02 mm)0.0345 in (0.88 mm)0.039 in (0.99 mm)
Weave, ends per inch16 x 14.5Not stated20 x 18Not stated
Widths36-96 in and 126 in36-96 in36-96 in and 126 in36-96 in; 120 in except Grey
Warranty10-year limited10-year exterior10-year limited10-year exterior

Textilene figures are from Twitchell's Textilene 80 and 90 specification sheet (February 2020), which gives one test sample per fabric with no color stated, at 0° and 45° profile angles. SunTex figures are from Phifer's SunTex 80/90 specification card (version V18B), which gives six colors at 30° and 75°; the ranges above cover all six at 30°. Textilene UV blocked is 100% minus its UV transmittance, and its shading coefficients are converted with the rule SHGC = 0.87 x SC from Efficient Window Coverings' exterior solar screen page.

Does an "80" fabric block 80%?

For Textilene, yes on solar energy and no on UV. For SunTex, no on either. Retail listings often read the name as "blocks 80%, so 20% open." Neither maker's sheet says that.

Twitchell says Textilene 80 "blocks up to 80% of the sun's rays." Its total solar transmittance is 24% straight on and 20% at a 45° sun, so "up to" is the 45° figure. The same table gives 23% openness and 33% UV transmittance, so Textilene 80 blocks 67-71% of UV. Textilene 90's "up to 90%" matches solar transmittance of 9-13%, while its UV blocked is 85%. Phifer states SunTex 80 as approximately 25% open and approximately 75% UV blocked, with solar transmittance of 26-31% at 30°.

The number in the name is a tier, not a spec. Compare openness and transmittance from the sheet, as our openness factor guide explains, never the names across brands. The same trap inside one brand is covered in SunTex 80 vs 90 vs 95.

Heat: a tie, once the two sheets are put on one scale

Twitchell tests at 0° and 45° and reports shading coefficient. Phifer tests at 30° and 75° and reports SHGC. Read straight, the sheets make the brands look further apart than they are. Converted to SHGC on single clear glass, Textilene 80 is about 0.29 at 0° and about 0.25 at 45°. SunTex 80 is 0.29-0.32 at 30° and 0.13-0.15 at 75°. Textilene 90 is about 0.20 at 0° and 0.17 at 45°, and SunTex 90 is 0.17-0.19 at 30° and 0.10 at 75°. Within a tier, the spread between brands is a few hundredths, about the same as the spread between colors of one brand.

Reading the sheets: SHGC is the fraction of the sun's heat that gets through glass and screen together; lower is cooler. The profile angle is the sun's height relative to the window, and a row at 0° is the worst case. Glossary: SHGC.

Two things move heat far more than brand. Going from 80 to 90 in either brand cuts SHGC by about a third, and Efficient Window Coverings puts solar screens mounted inside the glass at a shading coefficient of 0.50-0.70. The comparison against window film is in solar screens vs window tint.

UV and daylight: SunTex filters more of both

SunTex 80 blocks about 8 points more UV than Textilene 80 at 0° (approximately 75% against 67%), and SunTex 90 about 5 points more than Textilene 90 (90% against 85%). Efficient Window Coverings gives solar screens "Excellent UV protection (75-99%)," and Textilene 80 sits below that range on its own figures. If fading is why you are buying, that gap matters. How open area caps UV protection is explained in UPF and UV protection.

Daylight follows. Textilene 80 passes 21% of visible light at 0° and SunTex 80 36-39%; Textilene 90 passes 14% and SunTex 90 18-20%. The sheets do not explain the gap: Twitchell's sample color is not stated, and on Phifer's card color barely moves visible transmittance (Black SunTex 80 37%, Beige 39%). On the published figures, a room behind Textilene will be no brighter and may be dimmer. If daylight matters, hold a sample of the actual color up to the window.

Roll-down and zip screens: thickness, weight and the two Textilene 95s

On a screen that winds onto a tube, thickness sets the roll size and weight loads the motor. Textilene 80 is 18% thinner than SunTex 80 and Textilene 90 12% thinner than SunTex 90, which is also 9% heavier.

Worked example: A motorized screen 10 ft wide with an 8 ft (96 in) drop, wound on a 70 mm (2.76 in) tube. Roll diameter = square root of (tube diameter² + 4 x thickness x length / π), fabric only.
Textilene 80: 3.41 in. SunTex 80: 3.53 in. Textilene 90: 3.44 in. SunTex 90: 3.52 in.
Textilene Nano 95: 3.28 in. Textilene 95 (heavy): 3.55 in.
Fabric weight for the 80 sq ft panel: Textilene 80 7.2 lb, SunTex 80 7.5 lb, Textilene 90 8.8 lb, SunTex 90 9.6 lb, Nano 95 8.2 lb, Textilene 95 9.6 lb, SunTex 95 8.4 lb.

Within a tier the brands differ by about 1/8 in of roll. The two fabrics called "Textilene 95" differ by twice that. Twitchell's Nano 95 sheet calls it "lighter and finer" than the original: .014 in, 420 denier yarn at 36 x 34 ends per inch, 0.026 in thick, 14.7 oz/yd². Black at 45° passes 5% of solar energy, with an SHGC of 0.15 on single clear glass. Trivantage's Textilene 95 listing, a different fabric sold only through Trivantage, gives 17.3 oz/yd² and 0.0409 in: thicker than SunTex 80 and as heavy as SunTex 90. Its August 2025 launch post lists "zipper screens" among its uses. Phifer's counterpart to Nano 95 is SunTex 95, a "5% open basketweave" at 15.1 oz/yd² in Trivantage's listing.

Retract Wise analysis: the useful question for a motorized or zip screen is not "Textilene or SunTex" but "which grade did the screen maker rate this housing for". Our motorized screen housing sizes page shows a 4 in cassette paired with a 70 mm tube. A 3.3-3.6 in roll of fabric alone leaves little room in it, before the zipper edges and bottom bar are added. Swapping Nano 95 for the heavy Textilene 95 adds about 1/4 in of roll and 1.4 lb on this panel, which can decide whether a screen retracts fully or rubs.

Widths: Textilene 80 and 90 go to 126 in

Roll width caps a seamless roll-down panel unless the fabric is railroaded (turned sideways). Twitchell lists Textilene 80 and 90 at 36-96 in and 126 in, some colors only at 72, 96 and 126. Phifer lists SunTex 80 at 36-96 in and SunTex 90 adds 120 in "in all colors except Grey." For a 10 ft porch opening, 126 in Textilene covers it in one piece with 6 in to spare for hems; 120 in SunTex 90 leaves nothing. Nano 95 is 126 in on the January 2021 Nano 95 sample card, and SunTex 95 comes in 126 in only.

Strength, fire ratings and care

Both are vinyl-coated polyester. Twitchell gives grab tensile strength (ASTM D5034) of 305 lbf warp for Textilene 80 and 608 lbf for Textilene 90; Phifer gives "breaking strength" of 400 and 480 lb without naming the test, so the two cannot be compared. Where a fire marshal asks for NFPA 701, Twitchell's sheet names it for Textilene; Phifer's SunTex 80/90 card names California TB 117-2013, CAN/ULC-S 109 and Class A under IBC 803.1.1, so ask Phifer for the NFPA 701 test. Every fabric's listing, with method and edition, is in which solar screen fabrics are NFPA 701 rated. Bleach limits differ too: about 2% for Textilene, up to 10% for SunTex, as set out in how to clean retractable and solar screens.

When this comparison stops applying

  • Colors. Twitchell gives one unnamed sample per fabric. Phifer's own table shows color moving solar reflectance from 4% to 44%. A light SunTex and a dark Textilene of the same tier can differ more than the two brands do.
  • Other Textilene lines. Nano 97, Nano 99, Dim Out, PetTex and StormShield have their own sheets; none of the figures above apply.
  • Insect protection. Both weaves stop ordinary insects where the frame or track seals the edges. For the mesh-versus-mesh choice, see solar screens vs insect screens.
  • Re-screening an existing roller. Match the thickness of the fabric that came out, not the brand. The method is in how to rescreen a retractable screen.

Bottom line

On heat, Textilene and SunTex in the same tier are a tie: SHGC about 0.29-0.32 for the 80s and 0.17-0.20 for the 90s. Choose SunTex 80 or 90 when UV and fading matter, since it blocks about 75% and 90% against Textilene's 67% and 85%, and when you want more daylight. Choose Textilene 80 or 90 for openings that need a 126 in seamless panel, or where a thinner, lighter fabric helps the roll. For motorized and zip screens, use the roller grades (SunTex 95 or Textilene Nano 95), and check whether a "Textilene 95" on a quote is Nano 95 or the heavier 0.0409 in fabric.

Frequently asked questions

Which lasts longer, Textilene or SunTex?

The sheets do not settle it. Both carry 10-year warranties. Textilene reports "trace discoloration" after 1,200 hours of accelerated weathering, and Phifer's card publishes no weathering result.

Can I use Textilene 80 or 90 in a motorized zip screen?

Only if the screen maker lists it for that housing. Nano 95 is thinner and makes a smaller roll, and a SunTex 95 dealer listing calls it "thinner and lighter than traditional SunTex." See motorized patio screens for how the motor is sized.

Sources and standards consulted

  • Energy Efficient Window Attachments (U.S. Department of Energy, Energy Saver)
  • EN 13561:2015, External blinds and awnings (CEN)
  • ASCE 7, Minimum Design Loads for Buildings (wind and snow loads) (American Society of Civil Engineers)

See how we research for our sourcing and verification process.