Shade cloth vs solar screen for a patio

Use solar screen fabric if the shade has to roll up, run in side tracks or keep a view. Use shade cloth for fixed shade you tie or clip in place. And do not compare the two by their percentages, because they count different things. The "70%" on a shade cloth is its shade factor: the share of UV and visible light it stops, together. Its maker says plainly that this "is not a specific measurement" of UV block. The "80" in SunTex 80 is a product name, and Phifer's own card puts SunTex 80 at about 25% open and about 75% UV blocked. So a black 70% shade cloth can block more UV than SunTex 80, and a green one less.

Key takeaways

  • Shade factor = 100 minus the percent of UV and visible light that gets through. It is the number printed on shade cloth, and it is not UV block.
  • Color moves UV block a long way. Haverford's 70% shade cloth blocks 69.48% of UV in green and 94.2% in black, on the same sheet.
  • SunTex 80 and 90 are names. Phifer gives about 25% open and 75% UV blocked for SunTex 80, and about 10% open and 90% UV blocked for SunTex 90.
  • Only the solar screen sheet gives view and heat figures: visible light through of 36-39% (SunTex 80) and 18-20% (SunTex 90), plus heat gain figures on glass. The shade cloth sheets give neither.
  • Both carry 10-year warranties, but on different terms. Phifer replaces the fabric free, while Haverford's warranty is pro-rata, so it is worth less each year.

What the percentage on each one measures

Shade cloth is a knitted mesh of plastic yarn, sold by the roll for uses Haverford lists as horticulture, worksite screening, windbreaks and general home use. Its Quatra cloth is "100% Monofilament Knitted UV Stabilised HDPE." HDPE is high-density polyethylene, a tough plastic, and Ginegar's shade net is knitted HDPE too.

The percentage on shade cloth is its shade factor. In Australia, shade fabric is tested to AS 4174:2018, "Knitted and woven shade fabrics." ARPANSA, the national radiation agency, runs that test, and its reports give a UV-visible transmittance, which is how much UV and visible light passes through, and a shade factor. In each result, the two add up to 100. One fabric in a 2023 ARPANSA report passed 23.2% and had a shade factor of 76.8. So shade factor counts UV and visible light together, and it does not tell you how much of the UV alone is stopped.

That second number is UV block: the share of ultraviolet light (UVR on Australian reports) that does not get through. It is the number that matters for sunburn and fading. Haverford puts the difference in one line on its data sheet: "the Shade factor % is not a specific measurement of Ultra Violet Radiation (UVR) Block."

A solar screen is a woven mesh of vinyl-coated polyester, made to hang outside windows or across a patio opening. Its key number is the openness factor, the share of the fabric that is holes. Phifer's SunTex card lists "Approximately 25%" openness and "Approximately 75%" UV blockage for SunTex 80. For SunTex 90 it lists approximately 10% and 90%. The 80 and 90 are tier names, though retail copy often reads them as "blocks 80%," which the card does not say. The fabric is also far heavier than shade cloth: 457.73 g/m² for SunTex 80 and 583.18 g/m² for SunTex 90 on Phifer's card, against 180 or 250 g/m² for Haverford's 70% cloth and 60-65 g/m² for Ginegar's 35% net. Why the names and the specs differ is covered in SunTex 80 vs 90 vs 95, and openness itself in openness factor explained.

Shade cloth vs solar screen at a glance

Knitted HDPE shade cloth vs vinyl-coated polyester solar screen (sources listed at the end)
QuestionShade clothSolar screen (Phifer SunTex)
MaterialKnitted HDPE monofilament (Haverford, Ginegar)Vinyl-coated polyester
What the percentage meansShade factor: UV and visible light stopped togetherNothing measured: 80 and 90 are product names
UV blocked69.48% (green 70%) to 94.2% (black 70%), HaverfordAbout 75% (SunTex 80), about 90% (SunTex 90)
View and visible lightNot given on the sheets read36-39% (80), 18-20% (90) of visible light through
Heat figuresNone on the sheets readSolar transmittance and SHGC on glass, by color
Weight60-65 g/m² (Ginegar 35%); 180 or 250 g/m² (Haverford 70%)457.73 g/m² (80), 583.18 g/m² (90)
EdgeEyelet edging; cut edges do not unravelSpline in fixed frames, welded zip edge on zip screens
MovementShrinkage up to 2% (Ginegar)Held in a frame or tracks
Roll-up use named by the makerNoYes: Phifer's warranty covers SunTex "in retractable roller systems"
Warranty10 years pro-rata (Haverford)10 years, replacement fabric, no labor (Phifer)

UV: color decides more than the label

Haverford sells one 70% shade cloth in two colors. Its sheet gives UV block "as per AS 4173" (ARPANSA tests shade fabric to AS 4174:2018). Green blocks 69.48% of UV and black blocks 94.2%: same label, same maker, and a 25-point gap.

ARPANSA's May 2023 report for three Haverford knitted fabrics shows the same pattern from the other side. These are heavier cloths, 243 to 279 g/m², and the report does not give their product names.

ARPANSA test results for three Haverford knitted shade fabrics (AS 4174:2018, tested new, dry and unstretched)
ColorShade factorUV and visible light throughUV block
Sand76.8%23.2%89.2%
Grey80.5%19.5%88.1%
Black92.0%8.0%92.1%

For the sand cloth, UV block is 12 points above the shade factor, and for the black the two match. For Haverford's green 70%, UV block comes in just under the shade factor. So the label can understate UV block or slightly overstate it. Only a UV block figure answers the UV question.

Against that, SunTex is easy to read. Its UV figure is on the card: about 75% for SunTex 80 and about 90% for SunTex 90. A black shade cloth can beat both, while Haverford's green 70% falls below SunTex 80. Our UPF and UV protection page explains what those percentages mean for skin, and why a 90% block is only a modest UPF.

Not every shade cloth uses the Australian test. Ginegar's 35% black net gives a shade factor of 33-37% "by ASTM D 1746," an ASTM method, and no UV figure at all. A shade factor from one method is not on the same scale as one from the other.

View: only the solar screen is sold on it

Phifer prints a visual transmittance for every SunTex color, which is the share of visible light that gets through. SunTex 80 passes 36% to 39%, and SunTex 90 passes 18% to 20%. The card adds: "Dark colors provide maximum glare reduction and visibility."

Neither shade cloth sheet says anything about view. The ARPANSA report gives UV and visible light together, so it is not the same band as Phifer's figure. The nearest pair puts a 70% shade cloth at about 30% of light through, between SunTex 80 and SunTex 90, but that is a rough match, not a ranking. If you will sit and look out through the fabric, solar screen is the one made and measured for it.

Heat: only the solar screen publishes numbers

Phifer's card gives solar transmittance (TS), the share of the sun's whole energy that passes through. At a 30° sun, SunTex 80 passes 26-31% and SunTex 90 passes 12-17%. It also gives solar heat gain coefficient (SHGC), the share of the sun's heat that gets through a window with the screen outside it. On 1/8 in clear glass, that is 0.29-0.32 for SunTex 80 and 0.17-0.19 for SunTex 90. Color matters too: Black SunTex 80 reflects 4% of the sun's energy, and Stucco reflects 38%.

The shade cloth sheets read give no solar transmittance and no SHGC. Shade factor stops at UV and visible light, so it is not a heat figure either, and on these sheets nobody can rank shade cloth against solar screen on heat. If the job is cooling a room through glass, the solar screen is the one with figures you can plan from. How exterior screens compare with film on heat is in solar screens vs window tint.

Edge fixing: eyelets vs a frame or track

This is where the two part ways for a patio. Haverford's cloth comes with "Fabric Eyelet Edging," and because it is knitted, it "can be cut without unravelling." You fix it by its eyelets or clips to a frame, posts or cables, and the edges between fixings are free.

Shade cloth also moves. Ginegar gives a shrinkage rate of up to 2% at air temperatures up to 65°C (149°F). On a 96 in (8 ft) panel that is up to about 1.9 in, which a tied-in cloth can take up at its ties. Haverford gives no shrinkage figure.

Solar screen fabric is held on all sides. In a fixed frame, it is pressed into a groove with a spline. On a zip screen, a zipper strip is welded to each edge and runs in a side channel. That weld works by melting the fabric's PVC coating, as our zip track and zipper edges guide explains. HDPE shade cloth has no PVC coating to weld, and neither shade cloth sheet names a zip, spline or roller use. Phifer's warranty, by contrast, covers SunTex both as "exterior fixed screening" and "for use in retractable roller systems."

So the ruling is simple: if the shade has to roll up into a housing or run in tracks, it is a solar screen job. If it stays put, shade cloth on eyelets can do it. How zip screens are rated for wind is covered in zip-track screens and wind.

Lifespan and warranty

Both families carry 10-year warranties in the documents read, but the terms are not the same.

Haverford's cloth has a "10 year Pro-Rata UV Manufacturer's warranty." Pro-rata means the cover shrinks as the years pass, so a claim in year eight gets less back than a claim in year two. The sheet does not give the scale.

Phifer's Exterior Sun Control warranty says SunTex "will not become nonfunctional because of changes in physical properties" for ten years. A failed fabric is "replaced, free of charge, with an equal quantity" of fabric. The warranty does not cover labor, damage "from any source," or "gradual fading." The full terms, and other mills' warranties, are in how long do solar screens last.

Ginegar states its net's life as UV stability instead: 1,120 KLY by ASTM G 154. KLY is kilolangleys, a measure of sunlight received, and the sheet adds that the "world average is 140 KLY per year." Divide one by the other, and the rating is about 8 years of world-average sun. A sunnier site than average will use it up sooner, and that is the light 60-65 g/m² net, not a heavy patio cloth.

Worked example: Take a west-facing patio opening 12 ft wide with an 8 ft drop. Suppose the owner is choosing between a black 70% shade cloth on eyelets and a SunTex 90 zip screen. Read the labels first. The cloth's 70% is a shade factor, and Haverford's sheet gives the black 70% cloth a UV block of 94.2%. SunTex 90 blocks about 90%, so on UV the cloth is a little ahead.
Now light. A 70% shade factor lets about 30% of UV and visible light through. SunTex 90 passes 18-20% of visible light. These are not the same band, but the screen is clearly the darker of the two. For low western sun in the eyes, that counts.
Then the edges. The cloth hangs on eyelets and can move between them, and on Ginegar's figure it may shrink up to about 1.9 in over the 96 in drop. The zip screen holds both edges for the full height and rolls up into its box.
Worked through, the black cloth wins on UV block. The screen wins on glare, a sealed edge and roll-up use; the cloth would have to be untied to clear the opening. If the opening must be clear on cool evenings, the screen is the fit. If the shade stays up all summer, the black cloth does the UV job. A green 70% cloth, at 69.48% UV, would lose on both counts.

What this comparison does not cover

  • Shade over people. ARPANSA warns that a fabric's tested UV effectiveness "may be less than the measured value" under a real shade structure. It names structure height and size, stretching, distance from people, the sun's direction and sitting at the edge. A tested cloth is not a tested shade structure, and the fabric was tested new, dry and unstretched.
  • Other products. The figures are for Haverford's Quatra cloth, Ginegar's 35% black net, and Phifer SunTex 80 and 90. Other cloths and screens have their own sheets, and Twitchell's Textilene is set against SunTex in Textilene vs SunTex.
  • Bugs and airflow. A cloth on eyelets has open edges, so it does not keep insects out. A solar screen stops them only where its frame or track seals the edges. Denser fabrics also slow the breeze, as set out in do screens reduce airflow. For the insect side, see solar screens vs insect screens.
  • Wind on a tied cloth. No sheet read gives a wind rating for shade cloth or for SunTex as a fabric. Ask the maker of the frame or screen.

Bottom line

A shade cloth's percentage is its shade factor, the UV and visible light it stops together, and its maker says it is not UV block. SunTex 80 and 90 are names for fabrics about 25% and 10% open that block about 75% and 90% of UV. Compare UV block to UV block: black 70% cloth at 94.2% beats both SunTex grades, and green 70% cloth at 69.48% loses to both. Then decide on the edge: anything that rolls up, runs in tracks or must keep a clear view is a solar screen job. Fixed shade you can tie at eyelets is where shade cloth fits.

Sources

Frequently asked questions

Does 70% shade cloth block 70% of UV?

Not necessarily. The 70% is a shade factor, which counts UV and visible light together. Haverford's 70% cloth blocks 69.48% of UV in green and 94.2% in black.

Is 90% shade cloth the same as SunTex 90?

No. A 90% shade cloth stops about 90% of UV and visible light combined. SunTex 90 is a product name for a solar screen about 10% open that blocks about 90% of UV, per Phifer.

Can I put shade cloth in a roll-up or zip screen?

None of the sheets read lists it for that. Zip edges are welded to a PVC coating, which HDPE cloth does not have. Phifer's warranty covers SunTex in retractable roller systems.

Which color shade cloth blocks the most UV?

In the figures read, black. Haverford's black 70% blocks 94.2% of UV against 69.48% for green. ARPANSA's black sample also had the highest shade factor of the three tested.

Which lasts longer, shade cloth or solar screen?

Both carry 10-year warranties in the documents read. Phifer replaces failed SunTex fabric free; Haverford's warranty is pro-rata. Ginegar's light 35% net is rated at about 8 years of world-average sun.

Sources and standards consulted

  • Energy Efficient Window Attachments (U.S. Department of Energy, Energy Saver)
  • EN 13561:2015, External blinds and awnings (CEN)
  • ASCE 7, Minimum Design Loads for Buildings (wind and snow loads) (American Society of Civil Engineers)

See how we research for our sourcing and verification process.