Can an HOA ban solar screens in Florida?

Maybe not outright, but no one has settled it. Florida's solar law, section 163.04, bars HOA rules that ban "solar collectors, clotheslines, or other energy devices based on renewable resources." That is broader than the Texas and Arizona laws. But it never names screens, and we found no Florida court decision or attorney general opinion that does. The closest case is about tubular skylights, and there the association agreed they were covered. So "a Florida HOA can't ban solar screens" goes further than any ruling we found. What is settled: your board can make you apply first and ask how the screen will be installed. This is our reading, not legal advice.

Key takeaways

  • Section 163.04 protects "other energy devices based on renewable resources." It does not define that phrase, and it names no screen.
  • In the one appeal we found on a passive device, tubular skylights won because the association conceded they were covered. The court did not decide that point.
  • Even a protected device needs approval first. A board "cannot unreasonably deny permission," but it "can require information and assurance" about the installation.
  • Condo owners get the least help. The law covers devices "within the boundaries of a condominium unit" and does not apply to patio railings.
  • Legal fees go to whoever wins, under 163.04(3). If a court decides a screen is not covered, that can be the association.

What a solar screen is, and what Florida's law protects

A solar screen is a tight woven mesh fitted outside a window or across a patio or lanai opening. It blocks much of the sun's heat before it reaches the glass. It can sit in a fixed frame or roll down from a housing.

Florida's law protects three things: solar collectors, clotheslines, and "other energy devices based on renewable resources." A solar collector captures the sun's energy for use, as solar panels or a solar water heater do. The third phrase is the one that matters for screens, and section 163.04 never defines it.

That is why the Florida answer differs from our Texas and Arizona answer. Those laws define the protected device as one that works by "collecting and transferring" solar energy, which shuts screens out. In Florida, nothing in the text shuts them out, and nothing lets them in.

What section 163.04 says

The text has not changed since 2008. Four points matter here:

  • The ban on bans. A "deed restriction, covenant, declaration, or similar binding agreement" may not prohibit these devices "or have the effect of prohibiting" them. An owner "may not be denied permission" by whoever approves changes to property. This applies "with respect to residential dwellings and within the boundaries of a condominium unit."
  • The location rule. The association "may determine the specific location where solar collectors may be installed on the roof," facing south or within 45 degrees east or west of due south, if that does not "impair the effective operation" of the collectors. It says nothing about windows, walls or lanai openings.
  • Fees. In any lawsuit under the section, "the prevailing party" gets its costs and "reasonable attorney's fees."
  • The exclusion. "This section shall not apply to patio railings in condominiums, cooperatives, or apartments."

Many guides still quote the pre-2008 text, which covered "residential dwellings not exceeding three stories in height" instead.

What the courts have said

We searched CourtListener's case law for "163.04" with solar, skylight and screen, and the attorney general's opinions for "163.04," "solar" and "energy devices." Two published appeals deal with the section and an association. Neither involves a screen.

Taylor v. Ridge at the Bluffs Homeowner's Ass'n (Fla. 4th DCA 1991). Owners put solar pool heating panels on their roofs after the committee said no. The court held that the 1987 law regulated "political entities, not homeowners associations." The Legislature then amended it to reach associations.

Sorrentino v. River Run Condominium Ass'n (Fla. 5th DCA 2006). Condo owners asked to install two tubular skylights. A tubular skylight is a small dome on the roof with a tube that carries daylight down into a room. The board said no, the owners installed them anyway, and the association sued. At trial, "the parties stipulated that the skylights were energy-saving devices pursuant to section 163.04." The owners kept the skylights, and the appeal court sent the case back to set their attorney fees against the association.

The court also set the rule for Florida approval fights: "if the device is one protected by section 163.04, the Association cannot unreasonably deny permission to install it in a condominium unit or common element, but an Association can require information and assurance that the device will be properly installed."

Two more reports point the same way, without case names. A Florida Solar Energy Research and Education Foundation flier says owners won skylight cases, including on "common property," and the association paid fees. FSEC's solar rights page reports a case about "the installation of a garage door screen." It went the homeowner's way "because it was determined that the screen provided a means of cooling the residence, and as such, constituted a passive solar measure." We could not find that decision. (Our garage door screens guide covers the product.)

Retract Wise analysis: The garage door screen report is the best support for solar screens, and it is a one-line summary of an unnamed case. The skylight appeal shows a passive device can win, but only because the association conceded. Neither is a ruling you can hand a board. The statute's own list cuts both ways. A clothesline is as simple as a screen, which suggests the law reaches passive things. But a clothesline and a collector both put the sun to work, and a screen keeps it out.

Why "Florida HOAs can't ban solar screens" keeps circulating

The claim is old. A screen seller's blog, SunBlox Solar Screens, said on October 10, 2010 that under 163.04 an HOA "can't prevent a homeowner from utilizing or installing energy efficient products." It added: "This includes clotheslines, solar screens, and other products used for reduced power consumption." Clotheslines are in the statute. Solar screens are not, and "energy efficient products" is not the law's phrase.

Most Florida guides are about panels. Solar United Neighbors says the law forbids blocking an owner "from installing solar." With "solar" in the product's name, that sounds like it covers screens.

So which side is right? The "can't ban" claim states as settled law something no ruling we found has said. But "the statute names no screen" is too strong in Florida too, because the catch-all is undefined and one reported case treated a screen as passive solar. An outright ban is open to challenge. An approval step is not.

Houses in an HOA: section 720.3035

Section 720.3035 governs HOA architectural review. It never mentions screens or window coverings, but three parts shape a request:

  • A board can review "the location, size, type, or appearance" of an improvement only if that power is "specifically stated or reasonably inferred" in the declaration or its guidelines.
  • If the guidelines list options, such as screen colors, the board cannot stop you choosing from them.
  • A denial must be in writing, "stating with specificity the rule or covenant" relied on and the part that does not conform.

The section also makes boards approve hurricane protection that meets their specifications, and its list includes "roll-down track storm shutters." An ordinary solar screen is not hurricane protection, as our hurricane-rated screens guide explains, so that route does not help.

Condos: section 718.113 and the unit boundary

Condo owners have the weakest footing. Section 163.04 protects devices "within the boundaries of a condominium unit," and not on patio railings. Becker's Florida condo law blog notes that unit boundaries "vary from condominium to condominium," so your declaration decides what is inside your unit.

Section 718.113 does not mention screens either. It allows "no material alteration or substantial additions to the common elements" except as the declaration provides. If the declaration is silent, 75 percent of the voting interests must approve. Its hurricane rule lets a board require "an existing unified building scheme regarding the external appearance."

Worked example: one request, walked through

Suppose you own a house in a Florida HOA. You want motorized solar screens on a west-facing lanai, and the guidelines say exterior window coverings need approval.

Worked example: One solar screen request under the Florida rules.
1. Authority. The guidelines name window coverings, so the board's power is "specifically stated" under 720.3035. You apply.
2. The package. Send the items listed below, and say you consider the screen an energy device under 163.04. The Sorrentinos raised that only after installing, and the trial court faulted them for not trying to get approval first.
3. A denial over color. Say the board allows screens in bronze only, and you asked for charcoal. A color rule does not stop you having a screen, so the words "have the effect of prohibiting" are hard to stretch to it. Choose bronze, or ask for a variance.
4. A denial of all solar screens. Now 163.04 is in play. The written denial must name the rule. Your case is the undefined catch-all and the garage door screen report. The board's case is that a screen is not an energy device. No court has picked between them.
5. The fee risk. If you sue and win, Sorrentino says fees must be awarded. If a court rules a screen is not covered, the association is the prevailing party under 163.04(3).
Now move the screen to a condo balcony railing. Step 1 changes: railings are excluded by name, and the balcony may be outside your unit. You are back to the declaration and 718.113.

The statute only does work at step 4. Most requests stop at step 3.

Summary: what a Florida board can and cannot do

Florida solar screen rulings on this page, with their sources
QuestionAnswerSource
Can the board require you to apply first?Yes, even for a protected deviceSorrentino; FSEC solar rights page
Can it ask how the screen will be installed?Yes: "information and assurance"Sorrentino
Can it set color or frame?Likely, if the rule does not stop the screen itself163.04(2) wording
Does the south-facing location rule apply?No: it covers solar collectors on the roof163.04(2)
Can it ban solar screens outright?Unsettled. No case or AG opinion naming them foundCourtListener and AG searches
Must an HOA denial be in writing?Yes, naming the rule and the part that fails it720.3035(4)(a)
Is a condo balcony railing protected?No: patio railings are excluded163.04(4)
Who pays legal fees?The prevailing party, either side163.04(3); Sorrentino
Does the hurricane approval rule help?Not for an ordinary solar screen720.3035(6); 718.113(5)

What to send your association

  • A fabric sample and frame color. Pick from the board's list if it has one.
  • The product sheet. For a motorized patio screen, show the housing, its color and where it mounts.
  • The installer. Name, license and how the screen fastens. This is the "assurance" Sorrentino lets a board ask for.
  • The energy case. The fabric grade and what it blocks, from SunTex 80 vs 90 vs 95. Two Florida utilities in our solar screen rebates guide, OUC and Clay Electric, pay rebates for them.

The approval process in general is in permits, HOA rules and building codes.

Costly mistake: Installing first and citing 163.04 later. The Sorrentinos kept their skylights only after a lawsuit and an appeal, and the trial court found the board's first denial reasonable. A custom screen is built to the opening, so a removal order means paying twice.

Where this stops applying

This covers sections 163.04, 720.3035 and 718.113, the two appeals above and the FSEC reports. It does not cover cooperatives, apartments or leases. Trial court rulings are often unpublished, so a ruling that names solar screens may exist, and it would outrank this reading. A city permit or historic district review is a separate question. For a real dispute, ask a Florida lawyer who handles community association law.

Bottom line

Florida's law protects "other energy devices based on renewable resources," never defines them, and names no screen. No ruling we found covers solar screens. So a Florida HOA that bans every solar screen is on uncertain ground. But any board can require an application, ask how the screen will be installed, and likely set the color. Apply with a full package, mention 163.04 once, and order after approval is in writing.

Sources

Frequently asked questions

Is a solar screen a "solar collector" under Florida law?

Not in the ordinary sense. It does not capture the sun's energy for use. The open question is the catch-all, "other energy devices based on renewable resources," which the law never defines.

Can my Florida HOA make me remove solar screens I put up without approval?

It can sue to try. In Sorrentino the owners kept unapproved skylights, but the association had conceded they were covered and the installation was found sound. A screen has no such concession behind it. Ask whether an after-the-fact application is possible, and match the board's color list.

Can my condo board stop me putting a screen on my balcony?

Most likely, yes. Section 163.04 does not apply to patio railings in condominiums and protects only devices within the unit's boundaries. A screen on a common element also falls under the alteration rules in section 718.113.

Sources and standards consulted

  • Energy Efficient Window Attachments (U.S. Department of Energy, Energy Saver)
  • International Residential Code (IRC) and local permit requirements (ICC and local jurisdictions)
  • Published manufacturer warranty terms for frames, motors and fabrics (manufacturer documentation)

See how we research for our sourcing and verification process.