Can an HOA ban solar screens?
Yes, in most cases an HOA can regulate solar screens, and the solar laws will not stop it. Texas and Arizona both bar HOAs from banning a "solar energy device." But both laws define that as equipment that collects solar energy and moves it into heating, cooling or power. A solar screen does neither: it blocks sun before it reaches the glass. Arizona's definition goes further and leaves out anything that is "merely a part of a normal structure such as a window." So your board can set the screen color, the frame color and where screens go, and it can require approval first. We found no statute or court decision that names solar screens. This is our reading of the definitions, not legal advice.
Key takeaways
- Texas Property Code 202.010 and Arizona's ARS 33-1816 protect "solar energy devices." Both definitions turn on "collecting and transferring" solar energy. A solar screen does not do that.
- Arizona's definition says passive systems must be "clearly designed as a solar energy device such as a trombe wall and not merely a part of a normal structure such as a window."
- Even a protected device can be held to prior approval in Texas, and to placement rules in Arizona.
- All five HOA guidelines we read allow solar screens with approval. None bans them. All five set a color list, and four set a frame rule.
- The color lists differ. In our five, a brown screen fits four lists and a charcoal one fits two.
- Get written approval before you order. A custom screen is built to the opening, so a rejected color means new fabric.
What a solar screen is, and what the laws protect
A solar screen is a tightly woven mesh fitted outside a window or across a patio opening. It stops much of the sun's heat before it reaches the glass or the room. It can sit in a fixed frame or roll down from a housing.
A "solar energy device" is a legal term. In both states it means equipment that gathers the sun's energy and puts it to work, like solar panels. Whether a screen fits turns on three words in the definitions: "collecting and transferring."
Texas: Property Code 202.010
Section 202.010(b) says an HOA "may not include or enforce a provision in a dedicatory instrument that prohibits or restricts a property owner from installing a solar energy device." A dedicatory instrument is a governing document such as the deed restrictions or the guidelines.
The section borrows its definition from Tax Code 171.107. That reads: "a system or series of mechanisms designed primarily to provide heating or cooling or to produce electrical or mechanical power by collecting and transferring solar-generated energy." It also covers a device that stores that energy.
A solar screen helps with cooling, but by blocking sun, not by collecting and transferring energy. On the statute's words, it is outside the definition.
The Legislature's own record points the same way. In 2025 it passed HB 431, which added one sentence to the definition: "The term includes a solar roof tile." The author's statement said the code "does not recognize solar roof tiles as 'solar energy devices.'" If roof tiles that make power needed to be added by name, a screen that makes none is not covered by implication. The bill became law without the governor's signature on May 29, 2025.
Even for real solar devices, the Texas law leaves HOAs a lot of room. Under 202.010(d), a board can still prohibit a device that, among other cases:
- was installed without prior approval by the HOA or its committee;
- sits somewhere other than the roof or a fenced yard or patio;
- sits on the roof but extends past the roofline, or has a frame or bracket "not in a silver, bronze, or black tone";
- sits in a fenced yard or patio but is taller than the fence;
- voids material warranties as installed.
So even if a court read a screen into the law, prior approval would still apply.
Arizona: ARS 33-1816 and 44-1761
ARS 33-1816 says an association "shall not prohibit the installation or use of a solar energy device as defined in section 44-1761." It may adopt "reasonable rules regarding the placement" of a device, if they do not prevent installation, impair its function, or hurt its cost or efficiency. A second law, ARS 33-439, voids deed covenants that "effectively prohibit" such a device. It uses the same definition.
ARS 44-1761 defines the device as a system "designed primarily" to provide heating, cooling, power or solar daylighting "by means of collecting and transferring solar generated energy." Then it adds a line that matters here:
"Passive systems shall clearly be designed as a solar energy device such as a trombe wall and not merely a part of a normal structure such as a window."
A trombe wall, per the statute, is "a massive equator-facing wall that is painted in a dark color to absorb thermal energy from incident sunlight." It is built to soak up the sun's heat. A screen does the opposite: it keeps heat out. And a screen is an accessory to a window, which is the statute's own example of what does not count.
Solar daylighting does not help either. The statute defines it as a device that captures and redirects visible sunlight "for use in illuminating interior building spaces in lieu of artificial lighting." A screen cuts light; it does not redirect it.
| Question | Texas | Arizona |
|---|---|---|
| Law that limits the HOA | Property Code 202.010 | ARS 33-1816 (associations), ARS 33-439 (deed covenants) |
| Definition used | Tax Code 171.107, plus solar roof tiles since 2025 | ARS 44-1761 |
| Key words | "collecting and transferring solar-generated energy" | "collecting and transferring solar generated energy"; not "merely a part of a normal structure such as a window" |
| Does a solar screen fit, on the wording? | No: it blocks energy, it does not collect or transfer it | No: same reason, and it is part of a window |
| What an HOA can still require of a protected device | Prior approval; location, roofline, fence height and frame color rules | Reasonable placement rules that do not impair function or hurt cost or efficiency |
| Statute or case naming screens | None found | None found |
Why people think solar screens are protected
The word "solar" is in both names, and these laws are often called "solar rights" laws. The jump is easy to make.
HOA rulebooks themselves treat the two differently. The Los Alisos HOA guidelines in Scottsdale have a solar section that "applies only to the types of solar energy devices listed in ARS ยง 44-1761." Sunscreens sit in a different section, under windows, with their own color list. The Villages of Woodland Springs in Fort Worth does the same. Solar panels there are approved "subject to the requirements of applicable statutes." Solar screens are listed under screens and window treatments, with a color rule.
What five HOA guidelines say about solar screens
We read five sets of design guidelines that name sunscreens or solar screens, one from Texas and four from Arizona.
| Community and document | Approval | Screen color | Frame | Other rules |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| The Villages of Woodland Springs, Fort Worth, Texas (revised February 19, 2021) | "Solar screens are permitted subject to ACC approval" | Must appear "black, brown, cream or white from the exterior" | No rule | ACC has 60 days; then a second request to the Board, deemed approved after 45 more days with no reply |
| Los Alisos HOA, Scottsdale, Arizona (April 2017) | Prior written approval | Bronze, beige or charcoal | "consistent with the screen material or the existing window frames" | No reflective screens. Awnings and shade screens banned in front and side yards, with sunscreens excepted |
| The Highline Ranch HOA, Phoenix, Arizona (approved September 21, 2023) | Prior approval of the Architectural Committee | Bronze, gray, charcoal, brown or beige | "must match the screen material or existing window frames" | No reflective screens |
| Mountain Bridge Community Association, Mesa, Arizona (January 2017) | Submission for approval | Black or dark brown | Metal, "to match house or trim" | Color swatch required; kept in "like new" condition; weathered screens must be replaced |
| Venu at Grayhawk Condominium Association, Scottsdale, Arizona (revised February 15, 2022) | Design review; one named vendor | Brown, in "80% or 90% UV protection" | Adobe (a tan color) | No reflective screens. Same vendor named for exterior retractable shades; patio shades may instead match the building |
Every one allows solar screens, wants to see them first, and limits color to dark or neutral shades. Four of the five tie the frame to the screen, the window frames or the trim.
The front of the house gets the closest look. Los Alisos bars awnings and shade screens from the front and side yards, but carves out window sunscreens. A roll-down patio screen there belongs at the back. Three of the documents also ban reflective screens outright.
Worked example: picking a color that passes
Suppose you want solar screens on four west-facing windows, in charcoal, because dark mesh is easiest to see through (the openness factor guide explains why).
Los Alisos and Highline Ranch list charcoal. It fits, with a frame to match the fabric or the window frames.
Woodland Springs lists black, brown, cream and white. Charcoal is not on the list, so ask whether it "appears" black from the street.
Mountain Bridge allows black or dark brown only. Charcoal does not fit.
Venu at Grayhawk allows brown only, on an Adobe frame.
Now try brown. It fits Woodland Springs, Highline Ranch, Mountain Bridge (if dark) and Venu. It misses at Los Alisos, which lists bronze, not brown.
Charcoal fits two lists out of five. Brown fits four. Neither fits all five.
The lesson is not "buy brown." The color list changes from one community to the next, so read yours before you look at samples.
What to send your HOA
Use your HOA's own form, and attach:
- A fabric sample. A real swatch, not a photo. Mountain Bridge requires one.
- The frame color. Show it next to your window frames or trim.
- A photo mockup. Mark which windows or openings get screens, on which side of the house.
- The product sheet. For a roll-down or motorized patio screen, show the housing, its color and where it mounts.
- The fabric grade. Venu at Grayhawk names "80% or 90% UV protection." A board may ask.
The approval process itself, from reading the CC&Rs to timelines, is in our guide to permits, HOA rules and building codes.
Also check where the screen fastens. Screws into the window frame can raise a separate issue with the window maker, covered in do solar screens void a window warranty.
If the board says no
Ask for the reason and the rule in writing. Under these documents a refusal would rest on color, frame or location, which you can change, so resubmit with a listed color or ask for a variance. Do not lean on the solar statutes unless a lawyer says they apply. On their wording, they do not.
Where this stops applying
This covers the Texas and Arizona statutes named above and the five HOA documents we read. It does not cover other states, where solar access laws use other wording. Florida's law has no definition and protects "other energy devices based on renewable resources," so it reads differently; see can an HOA ban solar screens in Florida. We did not check Arizona's condominium statutes; ARS 33-1816 sits in the planned community law. We found no court decision or attorney general opinion on solar screens in either state. If one exists, it outranks this reading. Your CC&Rs can be stricter or looser than any rulebook here, and a city permit or historic district review is a separate question. For a real dispute, ask a lawyer who handles HOA law in your state.
Bottom line
In Texas and Arizona, the laws that stop HOAs from banning solar devices are written for equipment that collects and transfers solar energy. A solar screen blocks it, and Arizona's law leaves out parts of a window by name. So an HOA can usually require approval and set the color, the frame and where screens go. In the five rulebooks we read, none bans solar screens, all set colors, and all want to see them first. Read your color list, submit a sample and a mockup, and order only after the approval is in writing.
Sources
- Texas Property Code section 202.010, regulation of solar energy devices (text as amended in 2015; the 2025 change is HB 431, below). Read 2026-11-17.
- Texas Tax Code section 171.107, definition of solar energy device. Read 2026-11-17.
- Texas Legislature, HB 431, enrolled text (89th Legislature, 2025), bill analysis and bill history.
- Texas Legislature, HB 4455, introduced text (2023). This bill would have rewritten 202.010. Its history ends with a committee referral on March 21, 2023, so it is not law.
- Arizona Revised Statutes 33-1816, 33-439 and 44-1761. Read 2026-11-17.
- The Villages of Woodland Springs, Design Guidelines, revised February 19, 2021: window treatments, screens, solar panels, review timelines.
- Los Alisos Homeowner's Association, Architectural Design Guidelines, adopted April 2017: awnings, windows, solar energy devices.
- The Highline Ranch Homeowners Association, Architecture and Landscape Design Guidelines, approved September 21, 2023: sunscreens, window coverings.
- Mountain Bridge Community Association, Architectural and Community Guidelines, January 2017: windows and sunscreens.
- Venu at Grayhawk Condominium Association, Architectural Design Guidelines, revised February 15, 2022: windows, patio and balcony screens.
Frequently asked questions
Are solar screens a "solar energy device" under Texas law?
Not on the statute's wording. The definition needs a system that collects and transfers solar energy for heating, cooling or power. A screen blocks sunlight. No statute or court decision we found names screens either way.
Can my HOA make me take down solar screens I already put up?
If your documents require approval and you did not get it, the board can usually enforce that rule. Woodland Springs warns that unapproved items may have to be removed. Ask whether an after-the-fact application is possible, and match a listed color if you can.
Does the same answer apply to retractable or motorized screens?
Yes. A roll-down screen still blocks sun rather than collecting it. Some HOAs file patio screens under awnings rather than windows, so check both sections. Window options are in retractable window screens.
Can the HOA require a specific brand or installer?
Some do. Venu at Grayhawk, a condominium, names one approved vendor for window screens and exterior retractable shades. In a condo the outside walls are often common property, which gives the board more say.
Will a rebate or energy program override my HOA?
No. A utility rebate pays for a screen; it does not change your HOA's rules. The programs and their fabric rules are in solar screen tax credits and rebates.
Sources and standards consulted
- Energy Efficient Window Attachments (U.S. Department of Energy, Energy Saver)
- International Residential Code (IRC) and local permit requirements (ICC and local jurisdictions)
- Published manufacturer warranty terms for frames, motors and fabrics (manufacturer documentation)
See how we research for our sourcing and verification process.