Do solar screens crack windows? Thermal stress on double-pane glass

Not when the screen is fully down or fully up. Glass cracks from heat when the middle of a pane gets much hotter than its edges. The glass makers' bulletins list three ways that happens: heat trapped on the room side by blinds or drapes, glass or coatings that soak up sun, and shadows that cover part of the pane and stay put. An exterior solar screen fully lowered shades the whole pane, so it is none of those. The one habit to avoid is leaving a screen parked partway down for hours on sunny glass. That makes a fixed shadow across the pane, and Pilkington puts a fixed shadow at about 35% more stress than no shadow. It matters most on tinted or solar-control glass that is not heat treated. No glass maker document we read mentions exterior mesh screens at all.

Key takeaways

  • Thermal stress cracks start at the edge of the glass. The hot middle expands and pulls on the cooler edge held in the frame: about 50 psi for every °F of difference, per Pilkington.
  • The risk cases in the bulletins are room-side heat traps, sun-absorbing glass or coatings, and fixed partial shadows. None of them is an exterior screen that covers the whole pane.
  • A screen left halfway down makes a fixed shadow across the top of the pane. Run it all the way down or all the way up instead.
  • Ordinary double-pane glass with a low-e coating on the outer pane is rated low risk in Cardinal's worst-case tables. Tinted outer panes and solar-control coatings on the inner pane are where the risk ratings climb.
  • Tempered and heat-strengthened glass are strong enough that screen position is not a thermal stress concern.
  • If a pane does crack, most window warranties will not pay for it. Andersen's 2019 sheet excludes "stress cracks," and Pella excludes breakage "not the fault of Pella."

What thermal stress is, and why glass cracks from it

Thermal stress is the strain inside a pane of glass when one part of it is hotter than another. Glass grows a little when it warms. In a window, the middle of the pane sits in the sun. The edge is hidden in the frame, so it stays cooler. The warm middle tries to grow and the cool edge holds it back. That pulls the edge into tension, which is the kind of stress that breaks glass.

Pilkington's bulletin ATS-123 puts a number on it. The edge is stretched by "about 50 psi (pounds per square inch) for every degree ºF difference between the center and the edge." When the edge stress passes 2,000 to 3,000 psi, "the probability of breakage becomes significant." Cardinal IG, a large maker of the sealed units in home windows, uses the same 50 psi per °F in its own breakage method.

The bulletins are about annealed glass. That is ordinary window glass, cooled slowly with no extra heat treatment. Heat-strengthened and tempered glass are reheated and cooled fast, which makes them much stronger. Pilkington says both are "generally strong enough to prevent breakage from typical thermal stresses." Cardinal says heat treatment cuts thermal breakage to "less than 1 per 1,000" panes.

A double-pane window (an insulating glass unit, or IG unit) is two panes sealed around a gap. Each pane can crack on its own. Pilkington notes that double glazing raises the outer pane's share of absorbed sun and lowers the inner pane's, compared with each pane on its own. A low-e coating, which cuts heat flow, also "increases the resulting glass temperature and stress."

What the glass makers list as the risk cases

We read three makers' documents: Pilkington's ATS-123 (2013) and ATS-136 (2005), Vitro's Glass Education Center article on thermal stress, and Cardinal's bulletins IG24 (2020) and IG07 (2022). Their risk cases fall into three groups.

  • Heat traps on the room side. Pilkington lists "insulating blinds, drop ceilings below the level of the top of the glass, heat-absorbing labels or decorations on the glass." Vitro says indoor blinds and drapes raise glass temperature when they reflect "the solar radiation back through the glass." ATS-136 says blinds and draperies "must be placed 2" away from the glass, vented top and bottom," or have a lockout on the slats. It also warns that objects "on or against the glass, which impede natural air circulation, may cause high temporary stress."
  • Glass and coatings that absorb sun. Vitro says tinted glass is "more susceptible than clear glasses." Cardinal names "solar absorbing glass or coatings on the room side of the IG unit" as one typical case.
  • Shadows that stay put. Pilkington says overhangs "greater than 3" deep develop static shadows." Moving shadows add about 11% to the stress of an unshaded pane. Static shadows add about 35%. Vitro tells designers to limit places where "less than 50% of the glass panel is covered with shade." Cardinal lists "outdoor overhangs" too.

Cardinal adds the weather that makes it worst. Its tables model "a fully shaded window frame on a bright sunny cold day (typically the worst condition for thermal stress)." Cold edges and a sunlit middle give the biggest gap.

Worked example: a screen parked halfway down

Worked example: Take a west window with tinted, annealed glass. Suppose the solar screen comes down to the middle of the pane at 2 pm and stays there all afternoon. The top half is shaded. The bottom half is in full sun. That is the same shape as the overhang shadow in Pilkington's bulletin: a shaded band across the top that does not move. Now walk through the bulletin's own figures. Pilkington says sunlit heat-absorbing glass "can easily reach 40°F above" the outdoor air on a calm day. With the edge fully shielded, 40°F x 50 psi per °F gives 2,000 psi. A static shadow adds about 35%, so 2,000 x 1.35 = 2,700 psi. That lands inside the 2,000 to 3,000 psi band where Pilkington says breakage becomes a real chance. Lower the screen all the way and no hot half is left. Raise it all the way and the pane is back to the plain window its maker designed for. One point keeps this from being a screen figure. A solar screen lets some sun through its holes (its openness factor), so its shadow is lighter than a solid overhang's. No document gives a stress figure for a mesh shadow, so the 35% is the bulletin's number for a solid shadow, not for a screen.

The parked-halfway case is common on motorized screens. A Somfy RTS remote's "my" button sends the screen to a stored favorite position, which can be partway down (see awning remote not working). A sun sensor can also lower a screen on its own, as set out in motorized patio screens. Neither is a problem if the stop is at the bottom of the glass.

Where an exterior screen fits in those cases

Each row comes from a ruling above, with the document behind it.

Exterior solar screens and thermal stress, by situation (sources: Pilkington ATS-123 and ATS-136, Vitro, Cardinal IG07 and IG24, LBNL via the linked Retract Wise page)
SituationWhat the glass documents sayWhat to do
Screen fully down over the glassNot a listed case. The screen catches much of the sun before the glass: on double clear glass, LBNL puts SHGC at 0.59 bare and 0.10-0.34 with an exterior screenNothing
Screen fully upThe window as its maker designed itNothing
Screen parked partway, sun on the rest of the paneStatic shadow, about 35% more stress (Pilkington, heat-absorbing glass); limit panes under 50% shaded (Vitro)Run it to the bottom of the glass or all the way up, most of all on tinted or solar-control annealed glass
Screen parked partway on a cold, sunny dayCold, bright day with shaded edges is the worst case (Cardinal IG07)Raise it fully for the season
Fabric or frame pressed flat on the glassObjects against the glass that block air flow "may cause high temporary stress" (ATS-136)Keep a gap between screen and glass
Interior blind or drape closed tight to the glassHeat trap (ATS-123); reflects heat back into the glass (Vitro)Hang it 2 in from the glass, vented top and bottom (ATS-136)
Tempered or heat-strengthened glassUnder 1 break per 1,000 panes (Cardinal IG07); "generally strong enough" (Pilkington)Screen position is not a thermal concern

The first row is about where the heat goes. An exterior screen takes the sun before it reaches the glass, which is why it beats a glass-applied film on heat in solar screens vs window tint. The SHGC figures, the share of the sun's heat that gets through the window, are from LBNL's window attachments study as set out in should you take solar screens off in winter. That page also gives the season rule: raise retractable screens on south glass in heating climates. It fits the cold-day row here.

A gap behind the screen is normal on most mounts. A screen in side channels or a zip track hangs in front of the window opening, as on retractable window screens. Keep it that way, and do not let wind pin loose fabric to the glass.

Which double-pane glass is at risk

Cardinal's IG07 rates double-pane units by how much sun each pane absorbs, plus its field history. Even in its worst case, edges fully shaded and the middle in full sun, the common home setup rates low. That is a low-e coating on surface #2 (the inside face of the outer pane) with clear glass inside. It is "Low" for both panes at every glass thickness listed, 2.2 mm to 6 mm.

The higher ratings come from two places:

  • A clear outer pane with a solar-control low-e on surface #3, the outside face of the inner pane. Cardinal rates the inner pane "High" with its Lodz-366, Quad LoĒ-452+ and Lodz-340 coatings there. It says those coatings "are not recommended" in that spot "because of concerns for thermal stress breakage."
  • Tinted outer panes, most of all at 6 mm. Gray tint is rated "High" on the outer pane with every coating in the 6 mm table.

Cardinal calls anything over 55% total solar absorption on the outer pane high risk. You cannot see that number on a window. The label on the glass or spacer identifies the unit, and the window maker can tell you what glass and coating it has and whether it is tempered.

Why "solar screens damage windows" keeps circulating

The claim usually cited is a 2019 Budget Blinds franchise post, Pros and Cons of Getting Solar Screens in Pittsburgh. Read closely, it is not about heat. Under "They Can Damage Windows," it says screens "loosely added" can come away in bad weather and "flap about and scratch or break the windows." That is a fixing problem, and it is real. A screen that cannot flap cannot hit the glass. Side channels and zip edges hold the fabric, as covered in zip track screens and wind.

The thermal worry comes from window film, which sits on the glass itself. None of the bulletins names film either. The nearest case Pilkington lists is "heat-absorbing labels or decorations on the glass." Every window maker in our warranty set excludes film by name. An exterior screen gets lumped in because people weigh the two for the same window.

How to tell a thermal crack from an impact

Cardinal's IG24 shows the patterns. A thermal crack starts at the edge, and "thermal break patterns generally occur at 90 degrees to the edge of glass." Vitro says the same: the glass breaks "at a 90-degree angle in from the edge." An impact breaks glass into small pieces from one point, which may fall out of the opening. A crack from a forced sash, such as opening a casement with one lock still engaged, has its own pattern again. If a pane cracks with a screen fitted, note where the crack starts and photograph it before anyone removes the screen.

If a pane cracks: what the window warranty says

Window warranties are narrow on breakage, screen or no screen. In our reading for do solar screens void a window warranty, Andersen's 2019 Stormwatch and impact-resistant glass sheet excludes "Stress cracks and broken glass." Pella excludes "glass breakage not the fault of Pella." JELD-WEN's United Collection covers spontaneous breakage for 1 year, labor included. Marvin covers non-tempered glass against stress cracks "caused by manufacturing defects" for 10 years. Each of those turns on cause. A screen that never touched the window, and that you ran fully down or fully up, is hard to blame.

What this does not cover

No glass maker document we read mentions exterior mesh screens. Everything here is the bulletins' own mechanisms applied to where a screen sits. We give no stress figure for a screen, because no document has one. Pilkington's figures are for heat-absorbing glass and its shadow numbers come from mullions and overhangs. Cardinal's ratings are for its own glass in generic window sash and are, in its words, for "comparative purposes only." Glass with chipped or damaged edges is weaker than any of these figures assume. Pilkington stresses clean-cut edges, and Cardinal assumes minor edge damage in its sums. Triple-pane units, skylights and sloped glazing have their own risk cases that this page does not cover. If you have tinted or solar-control glass and plan to run screens partway as a habit, ask the window maker before you buy.

Bottom line

An exterior solar screen does not crack windows when it is fully down or fully up. The glass makers' thermal stress cases are room-side heat traps, sun-absorbing glass and coatings, and shadows that cover part of the pane and stay put. A screen parked halfway for hours makes that last kind, so run it to the bottom of the glass or raise it, above all on tinted or solar-control annealed glass and on cold, sunny days. Ordinary low-e double-pane glass rates low risk, and tempered glass is not a concern.

Sources

Frequently asked questions

Can solar screens cause thermal stress cracks?

Not in any case the glass makers describe when the screen is fully down or fully up. A screen parked partway for hours casts a fixed shadow across the pane, and Pilkington puts a fixed shadow at about 35% more stress than none. Run it all the way.

Is it bad to leave solar screens halfway down?

For an hour, no document suggests a problem. For whole afternoons on sunny tinted or solar-control glass that is not tempered, it is the one pattern that matches the bulletins' risk cases. Set your stop at the bottom of the glass.

Do solar screens make windows hotter?

An exterior screen takes the sun before it reaches the glass, which is why it cuts heat through the window so much. Interior blinds tight to the glass are the ones Vitro says raise glass temperature, by reflecting sun back through it.

Do interior solar shades crack windows?

They are closer to the bulletins' risk cases. Pilkington lists insulating blinds as a heat trap, and ATS-136 asks for blinds and drapes 2 in from the glass, vented top and bottom.

Will a cracked window be covered if I have solar screens?

Breakage is mostly excluded anyway. Andersen's 2019 sheet excludes stress cracks and Pella excludes breakage not its fault. JELD-WEN covers spontaneous breakage for 1 year, and Marvin covers stress cracks from manufacturing defects for 10.

Sources and standards consulted

  • EN 13561:2015, External blinds and awnings (covers vertical external screens and wind classes) (CEN)
  • Screen mesh specification sheets (fiberglass, polyester and PVC-coated meshes) (manufacturer documentation)
  • Energy Efficient Window Attachments (U.S. Department of Energy, Energy Saver)
  • Attachments Energy Rating Council (AERC) rating program (AERC)

See how we research for our sourcing and verification process.