Should you take solar screens off in winter?
Yes, on south-facing glass in a climate where you heat more than you cool. On a typical double-pane window, an exterior solar screen blocks about 40% to 83% of the sun's heat. That is free heat you want in January. The screen does add some insulation, but it only cuts the window's heat loss by about 18% to 35%. On a clear winter day the sun it blocks is worth several times the heat it saves. Leave screens up on west and east glass in hot climates, and on any window whose room overheats in winter sun. A retractable screen is the easy case: roll it up for the season.
Key takeaways
- On double clear glass, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory (LBNL) puts the window's solar heat gain coefficient (SHGC) at 0.59 bare and 0.10-0.34 with an exterior solar screen. The window loses 42-83% of its sun heat.
- The same screen moves the window's U-factor from 0.49 to 0.32-0.40, which means 18-35% less heat lost through the glass.
- Worked through for one south window on a clear January day at 40°N, the screen blocks about 3 to 11 times more heat than it saves.
- Direction matters most. At 40°N a south window gets more than twice the clear-day sun in January that it gets in July. East and west windows get less than half.
- Leave it up in hot climates, on north glass, and where a room runs too warm in winter sun. Retractable screens go up for the season anyway, because makers forbid running them in frost.
What a solar screen is, and the three numbers that decide this
An exterior solar screen is a dense, coated mesh fitted outside the glass. Most are vinyl-coated polyester, such as Phifer SunTex or Twitchell Textilene. They come as fixed panels in a frame or on a roller that pulls down and rolls back up. The weave is mostly solid: SunTex 90 is about 10% open and SunTex 80 about 25% (see SunTex 80 vs 90 vs 95). An insect screen is a different thing, about 60% open (see solar screens vs insect screens).
Three numbers settle the winter question:
- SHGC (solar heat gain coefficient). The share of the sun's heat that gets through the window, from 0 to 1. Lower is cooler. In winter, on a sunny window, higher is better. See SHGC in the glossary.
- Shading coefficient (SC). An older way to say the same thing. It compares a window with a plain single pane of clear glass. Efficient Window Coverings converts it as SHGC = 0.87 x SC.
- U-factor. How fast heat leaks out through the window, in Btu per hour per square foot per °F of temperature difference. Lower means better insulation.
Taking a screen down raises the SHGC, which lets the sun in. Leaving it up lowers the U-factor, which keeps heat in. The question is which effect is bigger.
How much winter sun a solar screen blocks, and how much heat it keeps in
LBNL's 2013 study for the U.S. Department of Energy gives both numbers for the same screens on three kinds of window. The screen range covers four modeled fabrics, from a low-e coated, solid weave down to one 30% open.
| Window | SHGC bare | SHGC with screen | Sun heat blocked (our calculation) | U-factor bare | U-factor with screen | Heat loss cut (our calculation) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Single clear | 0.78 | 0.12-0.45 | 42-85% | 1.06 | 0.41-0.66 | 38-61% |
| Double clear | 0.59 | 0.10-0.34 | 42-83% | 0.49 | 0.32-0.40 | 18-35% |
| Double low-e | 0.29 | 0.05-0.18 | 38-83% | 0.31 | 0.19-0.23 | 26-39% |
These match the other figures on this site. Efficient Window Coverings gives an exterior solar screen a shading coefficient of 0.14-0.33, or an SHGC of about 0.12-0.29. That is the range our solar screens vs window tint comparison works from.
Low winter sun gets through a screen more easily than high summer sun. It meets the weave more squarely, so more of it passes through the holes. Phifer's SunTex 80/90 card shows this. On 1 in clear insulating glass, SunTex 80 gives an SHGC of 0.23-0.27 (by color) with the sun at a 30° profile angle. With the sun at 75° it gives 0.09. SunTex 90 gives 0.14-0.16 at 30° and 0.06-0.07 at 75°. The noon sun at 40°N stands about 30° high in late January (our calculation), so the 30° row is the winter one. A screen blocks less in winter than its summer figures suggest. It still blocks most of the sun.
Worked example: one south window on a clear January day
Take a south window, 3 x 5 ft (15 sq ft), double clear glass, at 40°N, roughly the latitude of Philadelphia, Columbus or Denver. Suppose the day is clear, the house is kept at 70°F and it averages 30°F outside, a 40°F difference.
Bare window (SHGC 0.59, so SC 0.68): 1,626 x 0.68 = about 1,100 Btu per sq ft, or about 16,500 Btu for the window.
With the screen (SHGC 0.10-0.34): about 190-640 Btu per sq ft. The screen keeps out about 470-920 Btu per sq ft, or about 7,000-13,700 Btu for the window.
Insulation the screen adds: the U-factor drops by 0.09 to 0.17. Over 24 hours at a 40°F difference, that saves 0.09-0.17 x 40 x 24 = about 86-163 Btu per sq ft, or about 1,300-2,400 Btu for the window.
Net: even pairing the screen's best insulation with its most open weave, it blocks about three times what it saves. With the densest weave and least insulation, it is about eleven times. For this window, the screen comes out ahead only on a dull day. That means less than 10-35% of clear-day sun, depending on the weave (our calculation: 150-570 Btu per sq ft of the 1,626).
For one window on one clear day, 7,000-13,700 Btu is about a tenth of a therm of gas. That is small for one window and one day. It adds up over every south window and every sunny day from November to March. To turn your own windows into a seasonal bill, use the energy savings calculator.
Why the window's direction changes the answer
The same ASHRAE table explains why the advice splits by wall. Here is the clear-day sun through a plain pane at 40°N, by direction.
| Window faces | January | July | What it means for a solar screen |
|---|---|---|---|
| South | 1,626 | 704 | Most of its sun arrives in winter, when you want it. Take the screen down. |
| East or west | 514 | 1,189 | Most of its sun arrives in summer. The winter loss is small. A close call. |
| North | 122 | 446 | Little sun to lose in winter. Leave the screen up. |
Run the worked example on an east or west window and the screen keeps out about 150-290 Btu per sq ft on a clear January day. It saves 86-163 through insulation. That is close to even, and a cloudy day tips it toward the screen. So take an east or west screen down if that is easy, and leave it if not. On north glass the screen keeps out about 35-70 Btu per sq ft and saves 86-163. Leaving it up comes out ahead even on a clear day (our calculation, same method).
The Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL) reaches the same split from the other side. Its 2024 poster on window coverings lists solar screens among "the best shading methods for east- and west-facing windows." For south windows, it lists roof overhangs, porch roofs, balconies, awnings and Bahama shutters instead. An overhang over a south window blocks the high summer sun, and the low winter sun passes in under it.
What LBNL's whole-house model found
The worked example is one window on one day. LBNL modeled a whole two-story house of 2,400 sq ft in 12 U.S. cities, for a full year. Its window area was 15% of the floor area, spread evenly over all four walls. Its screens were raised and lowered on a schedule taken from a survey of 2,100 households. So these are screens used the way people really use window coverings, not screens left down all winter. The figures are total annual savings (heating plus cooling) against the same house with no screens, in a house with gas heat and electric air conditioning. Negative means the screen made the house use more energy.
| City | Double clear glass | Double low-e glass |
|---|---|---|
| Minneapolis | -3.0 / -2.3 / +1.6 | -4.1 / -3.5 / -1.3 |
| Boston | -3.5 / -2.6 / +0.9 | -4.4 / -3.8 / -1.7 |
| Chicago | -1.8 / -1.2 / +1.8 | -3.3 / -2.8 / -1.1 |
| Washington, DC | -2.0 / -1.3 / +1.5 | -3.6 / -3.1 / -1.4 |
| Atlanta | +2.1 / +2.5 / +3.3 | -1.2 / -0.9 / -0.1 |
| Tampa | +7.6 / +7.1 / +5.0 | +2.6 / +2.3 / +1.5 |
| Phoenix | +9.4 / +8.9 / +6.6 | +2.6 / +2.5 / +1.7 |
The 2% and 5% fabrics are tighter than SunTex 90. The 30% fabric is a little more open than SunTex 80 and lets more light through its yarns. We left out LBNL's fourth fabric, a low-e coated weave with no holes, because no solar screen we know of is built that way. One GJ is about 9.5 therms of gas.
Two patterns stand out. In the cold cities, the dense screens cost energy even though they also save on summer cooling. The most open screen, which lets the most winter sun through, does best there. In Phoenix and Tampa every screen saves energy on both kinds of glass. For the central climate zone, LBNL says solar screens "impose a penalty on heating energy." That makes them "largely ineffective in saving overall energy." In its south zone, it found "all window attachments save energy."
Single-pane glass is the exception. With a U-factor of 1.06, the insulation side is large, and LBNL's single-glazing table (Table 24) shows exterior solar screens saving energy in every city, Boston and Minneapolis included. Screens on the other walls of a single-pane house can stay. South glass is still worth clearing on sunny days. On single clear glass at 40°N, a south screen keeps out about 620-1,230 Btu per sq ft on a clear January day and saves about 380-620 (our calculation).
Why "leave them up for insulation" still circulates
Because it is half true. A screen outside the glass does slow heat loss, and LBNL's U-factors show it. The question was put to GreenBuildingAdvisor in 2010: could an exterior solar screen cut heat loss at night? Editor Martin Holladay answered, "I don't see why not." A second reply said the screens "may slightly reduce heat loss" by slowing air across the glass.
The same thread holds the other half. Stephen Thwaites recalled a test at "a Solar Test facility in Toronto about 15 years ago." As he remembered it, "Exterior screens should be removed in the winter," because their gain in insulating value "was more than offset by diminished solar gains to the room." He was writing from memory and named no report, and we have not found the study. It agrees with the numbers above.
Even ordinary insect screens cost winter sun. In 2009 BuildingGreen reported an informal test by the Midcoast Green Collaborative in Maine. Three dark soapstone tiles sat by a south window around noon on a sunny March day: one shaded, one in direct sun and one behind a screen. They read 76.7°F, 96.7°F and 88.7°F. From that, the group estimated that screens left up "block about 30-40% of the heat" that would otherwise come in. It put screens at "between 3-10% of total fuel." That figure rests on audits showing that sun through windows supplies 10-25% of a house's heating. This was a tile and an infrared thermometer, not a lab test. It points the same way, and a solar screen is far denser than the insect mesh tested.
Efficient Window Coverings is plain about it: "In climates with heating season, take down solar screens to increase solar gain and reduce heating costs."
Retractable screens are the easy case
A roll-up solar screen solves this with the button. Raise it for winter. You get the sun on the glass, and the screen is out of the frost. Our guide to zip screens in winter sets out why. Every screen maker we read that mentions snow says to bring the screen in. Renson's manual says not to operate its screen in frost at all. That rules out lowering the screen on cold nights to win back the insulation. It is a small gain and not worth running a screen that may freeze. Efficient Window Coverings gives a general rule for exterior shades. Deploy them to cut heat gain, and retract them "as weather and space conditioning indicates." The same goes for a room that runs too warm on sunny winter days. That sun is not doing useful heating, so leave that window's screen up.
A fixed screen is a seasonal choice. Taking it down means a ladder, clips and somewhere dry to store it. Clean it first, using the maker's mix from our solar screen cleaning guide. Taking it down every year adds handling. The SunTex and Textilene fabric warranties give the same term for fixed and roll-up use (see how long solar screens last). If you cannot face the ladder twice a year, put the effort into the south windows and leave the rest.
Leave it up or take it down: the ruling by window
| Your window | Winter ruling | Why (section) |
|---|---|---|
| Retractable or roll-up screen, any wall | Raise it for the season | Winter sun back, and makers forbid running screens in frost (Retractable screens) |
| Fixed screen, south glass, cold climate, double or low-e glass | Take it down | Blocks 3-11 times what it saves on a clear day; LBNL cold cities lose energy (Worked example, Whole-house model) |
| Fixed screen, east or west glass, cold climate | Either; take it down if it is easy | Winter loss about equal to the insulation gain (Direction) |
| Fixed screen, north glass | Leave it up | Saves more than it blocks, even on a clear day (Direction) |
| Hot climate (LBNL: Phoenix, Tampa) | Leave it up | Every screen saved energy on both glass types (Whole-house model) |
| Room that runs too warm in winter sun | Leave it up on that window | The sun is not doing useful heating there (Retractable screens: "as weather and space conditioning indicates") |
| Single-pane glass | Take south screens down; others can stay | Annual savings in every LBNL city, but south glass still loses on clear days (Whole-house model) |
Where this stops applying
- The figures are modeled and clear-day. The worked example uses ASHRAE's clear-day sun, so cloudy days shrink the loss. LBNL's results are for one house design with gas heat. A heat pump, a very leaky house or shaded windows will move the numbers. Trees, porches and neighbors that already shade a south window in winter remove most of the sun there is to lose.
- Your climate between the listed cities. LBNL modeled 12 cities, and we show seven. A mild city like Atlanta flips from saving on double clear glass to a small loss on low-e glass. Near that line, the screen's effect is small either way.
- Comfort, glare and privacy. This page weighs heat only. A screen kept up for glare on a TV wall or privacy on a street window may be worth the lost sun. That is your call, not an energy one.
- A specific product. The Attachments Energy Rating Council (AERC) rates solar screens with a separate cool-climate rating and warm-climate rating. If you are buying, the cool-climate number is the winter one. We could not load AERC's product directory for this page, so no certified product is named here.
Bottom line
Take exterior solar screens off south windows for winter if you heat more than you cool. On double-pane glass the screen blocks about 40-83% of the sun's heat and cuts heat loss by only 18-35%. On a clear January day that is three to eleven times more heat lost than saved. Raise retractable screens for the season anyway. Leave fixed screens up on north glass, in hot climates, and on any room that overheats in winter sun. East and west glass is close to a wash, so do those last.
Sources
- Curcija, D. C., Yazdanian, M., Kohler, C. and Hart, R., Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Energy Savings from Window Attachments, U.S. Department of Energy, October 2013. U-factor and SHGC from Tables 13-15; annual savings from Appendix B, Tables 24, 28 and 32. The main-body Tables 21-23 print the Washington, DC and Phoenix column headings in swapped order; we used the per-city appendix.
- Efficient Window Coverings, Exterior solar screen and Exterior roller shade.
- Phifer, SunTex 80/90 sample card (V18B), hosted by Trivantage. SHGC (g-tot, glass and fabric) on 1 in clear insulating glass, fabric installed externally.
- ASHRAE Handbook of Fundamentals, solar heat gain factors, daily totals, as tabulated in Solar Heat Gain Factors for selected latitudes (Dartmouth, ENGS 44).
- Gilbride, T., Pacific Northwest National Laboratory, Window Coverings that Can Take the Heat, poster, August 2024.
- BuildingGreen, How Window Screens Affect Winter Fuel Use in Heating Climates, January 20, 2009, reporting a test by the Midcoast Green Collaborative.
- GreenBuildingAdvisor, Do exterior solar screens provide radiant barrier to heat loss?, question and replies, March 2010.
- Attachments Energy Rating Council, Reading the residential label.
Frequently asked questions
Do solar screens keep a house warmer in winter?
At night, a little: LBNL's figures show an exterior screen cutting a double-pane window's heat loss by 18-35%. In the day they block 42-83% of the sun's heat, so on a sunny south window they make the room cooler, not warmer.
Should I take off insect screens in winter too?
On south windows in a cold climate it helps. In an informal test reported by BuildingGreen, a plain insect screen blocked about 30-40% of the sun's heat. Solar screens block more, so they matter more.
Are solar screens worth it if I have to take them down every winter?
On east and west glass you may not need to. Those windows get most of their sun in summer, and in winter the screen roughly breaks even. Fixed screens on south glass are the ones to move, and a retractable screen avoids the chore.
Does a darker solar screen change the winter answer?
Only a little. On Phifer's SunTex 80 card, the winter-angle SHGC runs from 0.23 for grey to 0.27 for beige on insulating glass. Openness matters more: SunTex 90 sits at 0.14-0.16. For how openness and color trade off, see screen mesh openness factor.
Sources and standards consulted
- Fabric mill cleaning and care instructions for solution-dyed acrylic and coated polyester (manufacturer documentation)
- Tubular motor troubleshooting and limit-setting guides (manufacturer documentation)
- EN 13561:2015 wind resistance classes (CEN)
- Beaufort wind force scale (World Meteorological Organization)
See how we research for our sourcing and verification process.